Wow, tonight was pretty bad. I expected a great night after hearing that it was Motown but what a letdown. I can't believe they brought guest judges agian this year. Once again, where's Lisa Leuschner amid some of this dreck?
Here's my rankings:
1. George: The only one who captured the Motown style properly.
2. Jasmine: Great improvement from last week.
3. Fantasia: Very consistent.
4. Latoya: Not her best but so much better than some of the others.
5. Amy: Good, but not great.
6. Diana: Great voice but she's like a robot on stage. Everything seems so rehearsed, right down to her reactions to the judges critiques.
7. Jennifer: Just ok, the song seemed like it wasn't going anywhere.
8. Camille: I think she needs another couple of years to mature into a better singer.
9. JPL: He's so out of his league. That was not Motown, it was just foolishness.
10. John Stevens: Worst performance of the season. Even the crowd, who usually boo when a judge gives a bad review, were quiet.
I think the bottom 3 will be Latoya(only because she performed early), Camille, and John Stevens, with Camille going home.
Here's my rankings:
1. George: The only one who captured the Motown style properly.
2. Jasmine: Great improvement from last week.
3. Fantasia: Very consistent.
4. Latoya: Not her best but so much better than some of the others.
5. Amy: Good, but not great.
6. Diana: Great voice but she's like a robot on stage. Everything seems so rehearsed, right down to her reactions to the judges critiques.
7. Jennifer: Just ok, the song seemed like it wasn't going anywhere.
8. Camille: I think she needs another couple of years to mature into a better singer.
9. JPL: He's so out of his league. That was not Motown, it was just foolishness.
10. John Stevens: Worst performance of the season. Even the crowd, who usually boo when a judge gives a bad review, were quiet.
I think the bottom 3 will be Latoya(only because she performed early), Camille, and John Stevens, with Camille going home.
Last edited: