^^ Yeah, it's really too bad. Caroline & Michael are so interesting and creative. I wonder why they were talked into going so conventional in the FD. I thought their RD was okay, but under-scored. They seemed more subdued and cautious in the FD after those low-ball scores in the RD.
I totally agree with you about Ian & Emily too. I liked their program choices last season in their debut as partners. I think those programs were by Charlie. If Tanith made the choices for them this season, she's done them no favors. Same goes if Tanith is behind G/P's new FD.
Re Ian & Em, they have a good dynamic. I suppose Emily is a bit more skilled than Ian's former partner, Kat DelCamp, technically. OTOH, Kat has more presence and dramatic flair. Sad that Kat is no longer partnered with U.K.'s Billy Wilson-French. Apparently, after training for awhile in Britain and in the U.S., something wasn't working and they split.
Honestly, Ian's best partnership was with Eliana Gropman. They were well-suited physically and skill-wise, having grown up learning and competing in ice dance together. Something went wrong when she applied for college in Michigan. Ian hooked up with Kat D whom he was dating off-ice. They had a great connection on and off-the-ice, but Kat needed more seasoning in juniors and Ian needed to move on to seniors.
Emily Bratti is a good partner, but her skill level needs to improve to fully match Ian's. Plus, Emily is slightly taller than Kat and Eliana. If only Ian and Eliana had weathered their upset. It seemingly would have been possible for Eliana to attend school in Michigan while switching with Ian to Canton to train. Especially since that's where Ian has subsequently ended up. But I suppose timing is everything, and getting along personality-wise is important too.