- Joined
- Jul 11, 2019
fingers crossed for Dabin and Minchae to replace the spot of A&C at at least one event once they WDI couldn't find a separate thread for this, so here goes:
Women
2. Minchae Kim - Kor 184.03
15. Dabin Choi - Kor 171.00
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
fingers crossed for Dabin and Minchae to replace the spot of A&C at at least one event once they WDI couldn't find a separate thread for this, so here goes:
Women
2. Minchae Kim - Kor 184.03
15. Dabin Choi - Kor 171.00
I wonder if anyone know anything about Minchae. She hasn´t been competing for a while, and didn´t even reach the final in the last competition she did, a local event in November, she placed 25th and scored 44 points in her SP. She didn´t compete at Korean Nationals..fingers crossed for Dabin and Minchae to replace the spot of A&C at at least one event once they WD
Hmmm... I think Sarina has a good chance to get a GP spot so i´m not sure she wants to stay in JGP. She perhaps has a chance to have a higher placement in JGP but it depends on what she wants to achieve. If she wants to collect most WR points GP potentially has more points to give for lower placements. Top 3 at JGP is worth less than top 7 at GP. However if she is in a very strong field in GP even making top 8 to get WR points can be difficult, because she might get underscored because of reputation. In JGP she only needs to be top 10 to get some points which she likely will (off course it will depend on the rest of the entries).Sarina, Anna and Elyce are still Junior-eligible and might choose to compete on the JGP circuit instead. I guess we'll know pretty soon with Elyce, as the US Junior Team Cup is happening soon.![]()
Thank you @Jumping_Bean! I was already hoping for Daria and Michel to get a second assignment, and they are close (second on the list). Fingers crossed!Ice Dance
*Teams with one assignment already
- Isabella FLORES / Ivan DESYATOV - USA - 180.62
- Jennifer JANSE VAN RENSBURG / Benjamin STEFFAN - GER - 179.42*
- Marie DUPAYAGE / Thomas NABAIS - FRA - 179.05*
- Holly HARRIS / Jason CHAN - AUS - 176.34*
- Alicia FABBRI / Paul AYER - CAN - 173.34*
- Katarina WOLFKOSTIN / Dimitry TSAREVSKI - USA - 172.88
- Carolane SOUCISSE / Shane FIRUS - IRL - 171.67
- Elizabeth TKACHENKO / Alexei KILIAKOV - ISR - 170.33*
- Phebe BEKKER / James HERNANDEZ - GBR - 169.74
- Sofia VAL / Asaf KAZIMOV - ESP - 168.34
- Victoria MANNI / Carlo ROETHLISBERGER - ITA - 168.23
- Nadiia BASHYNSKA / Peter BEAUMONT - CAN - 167.87
- Mariia PINCHUK / Mykyta POGORIELOV - UKR - 167.22*
- Utana YOSHIDA / Masaya MORITA - JPN - 166.13*
- Natacha LAGOUGE / Arnaud CAFFA - FRA - 164.14
- Mariia NOSOVITSKAYA / Mikhail NOSOVITSKIY - ISR - 164.08
- Solene MAZINGUE / Marko Jevgeni GAIDAJENKO - EST - 163.75
- Milla Ruud REITAN / Nikolaj MAJOROV - SWE - 160.76
- Azusa TANAKA / Shingo NISHIYAMA - JPN - 158.69*
- Anna SIMOVA / Kirill AKSENOV - SVK - 157.73
- Lily HENSEN / Nathan LICKERS - CAN - 157.48
- Paulina RAMANAUSKAITE / Deividas KIZALA - LTU - 156.91
- Lou TERREAUX / Noe PERRON - FRA - 155.92
- Zoe LARSON / Andrii KAPRAN - UKR - 154.36
- Leia DOZZI / Pietro PAPETTI - ITA - 154.3
- Charise MATTHAEI / Max LIEBERS - GER - 153.04
- Mariia IGNATEVA / Danijil Leonyidovics SZEMKO - HUN - 152.96
- Layla KARNES / Liam CARR - GBR - 149.97
- Shira ICHILOV / Dmytriy KRAVCHENKO - ISR - 149.09
- Sofiia DOVHAL / Wiktor KULESZA - POL - 147.83
Pairs
*Teams with one assignment already
- Alisa EFIMOVA / Misha MITROFANOV - USA - 186.17 - Returning split couple*
- Daria DANILOVA / Michel TSIBA - NED - 177.54*
- Fiona BOMBARDIER / Benjamin MIMAR - CAN - 166 - Returning split couple
- Sofiia HOLICHENKO / Artem DARENSKYI - UKR - 162.17
- Anastasia VAIPAN-LAW / Luke DIGBY - GBR - 159.82*
- Ioulia CHTCHETININA / Michal WOZNIAK - POL - 159.15
- Isabelle MARTINS / Ryan BEDARD - USA - 154.66
- Oceane PIEGAD / Denys STREKALIN - FRA - 153.81*
- Sophia SCHALLER / Livio MAYR - AUT - 150.35
- Naomi WILLIAMS / Lachlan LEWER - USA - 146*
- Barbora KUCIANOVA / Martin BIDAR - CZE - 144.63
- Isabella GAMEZ / Aleksandr KOROVIN - PHI - 142.86
- Lydia SMART / Harry MATTICK - GBR - 140.46
- Yuchen WANG / Lei ZHU - CHN - 139.56
- Greta CRAFOORD / John CRAFOORD - SWE - 139.38
- Irma CALDARA / Riccardo MAGLIO - ITA - 139.15
- Letizia ROSCHER / Luis SCHUSTER - GER - 138.4
- Yuna NAGAOKA / Sumitada MORIGUCHI - JPN - 135.39*
- Maria MOKHOVA / Ivan MOKHOV - USA - 134.81
- Louise EHRHARD / Matthis PELLEGRIS - FRA - 132.5
- Aurelie FAULA / Theo BELLE - FRA - 131.07
- Yixi YANG / Shunyang DENG - CHN - 129.79
- Julia MAUDER / Johannes WILKINSON - RSA - 117.04
Caveat: No minimum score has been announced yet. It was 133.30 last season, so the teams ranked 20th to 23rd would not initially be eligible for non-host spots. Ehrhard/Pellegris and Yang/Deng are still Jr eligible, but both have indicated moving to Seniors this season.
The replacement list for SkAm currently would be:Right now I do not think Dabin can be picked to replace at Skam since she technically isn´t top 10 at the replacement list, but as other said here, if some of the girls above her on the list will compete at JGP instead, she might be top 10 before they do the replacement. So who knows? But I wouldn´t put my bet on that. From my understanding it will mostly be up to the host to pick from top 10?
Even if the list is short this year, it's actually not very likely that there will be enough withdrawals to reach the end of the list. On average, in years not directly after the Olympics, there are 29 withdrawals across all four disciplines, which is probably approximately the number needed to reach the end of the replacement list for at least one GP.On that note... since the women list is so short this year and some of them might not even be an option, what would happen if it turned out they came to the very end of the list and no more options for replacement? I think we can assume they would not allow more than 3 entries from one country in each discipline in this situation? Would they extend the replacement list above top 75, or would they start to offer spots from WR from top 25 and further? Or would the host pick freely? Or - will they be forced to leave a spot empty?
As @Jumping_Bean showed in their list, Dabin Choi would be 10th on the replacement list assuming that all the listed alternates are confirmed to be competing in that discipline this season if not already assigned to a GP. That list is specific to Skate America.I have a question on why dabin choi cannot be picked as a replacement for Skate America. I don't understand the rules very well; the top 10 skaters on the list must be given priority?
The ranking will be different for each GP since there would be countries that have the maximum number of entries in one (such as a host, or a country that qualified many skaters for the series.) That takes them off the alternate list for that competition since they cannot be assigned. Or the alternate may already be assigned to that competition, so they would be skipped over.The alternate list needs to be worked through in ranking order for the top 75 ranked Skaters/Couples according to their Season’s Best. All Skaters/Couples of the alternate list will be grouped in top ranked groups of ten Skaters, out of which the respective Organizing ISU Member may pick one Skater/Couple for invitation.
I had no idea that the replacement list was different for EACH grand prix. Logically, I guess it makes sense. But if haein is taken off the list for skate America, it's not automatically another Korean skater who takes her place?As @Jumping_Bean showed in their list, Dabin Choi would be 10th on the replacement list assuming that all the listed alternates are confirmed to be competing in that discipline this season if not already assigned to a GP. That list is specific to Skate America.
The rule for alternates is:
The ranking will be different for each GP since there would be countries that have the maximum number of entries in one (such as a host, or a country that qualified many skaters for the series.) That takes them off the alternate list for that competition since they cannot be assigned. Or the alternate may already be assigned to that competition, so they would be skipped over.
And if anyone withdraws from an assignment, they will not be given another assignment as an alternate.
It's not automatic that skaters are replaced with skaters from the same country. It's up to the host federation to decide who the replacement will be from the available alternates. USFS could decide to use Tzu-Han Ting for example, since she would be close by due to training in Toronto.I had no idea that the replacement list was different for EACH grand prix. Logically, I guess it makes sense. But if haein is taken off the list for skate America, it's not automatically another Korean skater who takes her place?
Here - https://www.isu.org/docman-document...es-files-58/31498-general-announcement-2/fileWhere is the rules document about GP alternates on the ISU website? When I click on the general announcement for the 2024/25 GP, it takes me to the Announcement for the Challenger Series instead.![]()
![]()
Thanks. You know you're a figure skating fan when you bother to read the official rules for competitions or the sport itself.Here - https://www.isu.org/docman-document...es-files-58/31498-general-announcement-2/file
This is from last year, but the rules should be the same for this year.

Thanks, I was looking for the rules myself and just got frustrated with the wrong link the ISU provided.Here - https://www.isu.org/docman-document...es-files-58/31498-general-announcement-2/file
This is from last year, but the rules should be the same for this year.
I agree. I find it ridiculous with these groups-of-ten. It is much fairer to pick the first eligible one on the list. I find this rule just stupid.Replacing someone on the GP sort of feels like a lottery; either they pick you or they don't.
As next season is an olympic season, I would think the former juniors would like to try out the senior circuit as soon as possible?Sarina, Anna and Elyce are still Junior-eligible and might choose to compete on the JGP circuit instead. I guess we'll know pretty soon with Elyce, as the US Junior Team Cup is happening soon.![]()