- Joined
- Dec 4, 2004
Tear falls.......Georgian judge giving georgian team higher PCS and GOEs than Charco (and lala)
(Elena Khmyzenko, former russian judge who switched fed to geo, just like skaters)
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Tear falls.......Georgian judge giving georgian team higher PCS and GOEs than Charco (and lala)
(Elena Khmyzenko, former russian judge who switched fed to geo, just like skaters)
Louise Walden is a former ice dancer. She may not be the best commentator, but she knows more about skating - and ice dance in particular - than many.I don't know her, but Louise is obviously a non-authoritative voice and irrelevant to the world of skating, as Chock and Bates have just set a world record (I think) and brought the house down.
You should probably shop around for a channel with a better commentator.
Yeah I understand all that but what I don’t get is why Piper and Paul are then not scoring similar to C/B? They def have complicated choreo and seem to get dinged when they are not fast but if C/B have a slow day they still get really high scores. Their RD twizzles yesterday were slooow but they still got crazy GOE. I felt like I understood the judging better the last 3 years but this Olympic year I don’t understand what the judges are doing because the rules don’t seem to be applied consistently across events or teams apart from C/B. If C/B was a Russian team and being treated this way, people on this forum would be going nuts about it.Slow or fast can vary from day to day. If they are on, they will be faster than most. If they skate nervous, they might be average. From what I've seen of them live, they are neither the fastest or slowest team similar to Piper/Paul. But, they are magnetic. Both of the above teams skate in hold more than more modern ( faster) teams like the French or La/ La. It's harder to skate fast with interesting changing holds, close skating and complex choreo. Easier with open skating. The Italians are noticeably faster than C/ B and P/ P and they do it with complicated choreo and hold. ( Which is why they are my favorites, but clearly not the judges favorites)
So true!If C/B was a Russian team and being treated this way, people on this forum would be going nuts about it.
Thank you for sharing your observationsChock and Bates look slower on screen than they are in person. I see what everyone else does when I watch at home, they look slow, but I've been luck enough to see them in person and they aren't noticeably slower than other top teams in real life.
I think that Skate Canada expected a skate like that from Stephen. I actually did as well... but didn't expect the "top guns" to falter as much so that the judges, had to place them below Stephen.The entries for the Free Dance weren't due until after the Mens SP finished. There wasn't much time to make a decision, but there was time.
If I'd been the man in charge, I'd have had both teams ready for a last-minute call.
I am dreadfully fearful that P/P are going to be (outrageously) slotted behind the Brits, and I very much want them to leave with a medal. This team medal may be their best shot.
But, as you say, the die has been cast, and we can only hope for the best.
Edit: There surely had to entertain the possibility that Steven would have skated a blinder. He's not the most consistent, but when he's on.... and he's been skating very well recently. It had to be in the back of their minds that he could overperform expectations.
Oh, that’s what was different today. I think that this did make a difference in a going way.I appreciate that Zach tucked in his shirt today to better accentuate his body line. It makes them look more mature and senior; the details do matter.
They didn't expect the top guns to falter? Have they been to a men's competition?I think that Skate Canada expected a skate like that from Stephen. I actually did as well... but didn't expect the "top guns" to falter as much so that the judges, had to place them below Stephen.
well all three of them... you know.. Canadians are very humble people.They didn't expect the top guns to falter? Have they been to a men's competition?
They missed that part of the internet that is all about menning and cactusing.They didn't expect the top guns to falter? Have they been to a men's competition?
I wish my HBO Max had that. That would be awesome.Why is he even commenting figure skating? If you still consider hbo max, there is 'no commentary' option as well as other countries commentary
It was available for men, not for ice dance though. Still, great.I wish my HBO Max had that. That would be awesome.
Not in the US I don’t thinkIt was available for men, not for ice dance though. Still, great.
I don't know. Feels like people are going plenty nuts with them being from the USA (or for just not being P&P)So true!
Hope you are feeling better.Sorry folks I have not been commenting as I am watching a bit delayed. I am also a bit too nervous for the skaters.
I'm the same waySorry folks I have not been commenting as I am watching a bit delayed. I am also a bit too nervous for the skaters.
also ironically still kind of jetlagged (ironic, because I was in Italy last week... yes I left before the Olympics started