- Joined
- Jun 21, 2003
I did not assume any + GOEs.slutskayafan21 said:Fair enough, but I think it is wrong to assume any +GOE gain on jumps for Sasha that she lost on. Only 1 of her 3 jumps in the short had +GOE, and only 1 of 4 in the long did. Her triple lutz usually has slight -GOE even when she does it since it is flutzed. Her triple-triple sequence rarely does either. Even Irina was not getting much at all +GOE on her jumps, and she is clearly a better jumper then Sasha, although her jumps that night were sluggish for her standards, even the ones she landed I Mean.
She got -3.00 GOE on her Lutz, plus -1.00 for the fall; -2.86 on her flip, and -1.14 on her sequence.
Putting all these to 0 gives her a net gain of 8.00 points.
Again, I am not trying to guess whether Sasha might have got higher or lower scores if she had skated better or worse. I am trying to say that IMO she was rewarded correctly for what she did well, and punished appropriately for her mistakes.