They were. And so young (both of them). Looking good for the future!Also how amazing were Ash and Atl, they are just a joy to watch
I'm gutted for Phebe and James. I also thought they deserved the bronze. Lift deductions. Pfft.Im kind of salty they didn't get that bronze I think they deserved it :/ but I'm so proud of them anyway. They still haven't even been together that long
I hate lift deductions forever
Also how amazing were Ash and Atl, they are just a joy to watch
This is referring to the combination lifts in the FD, yes? I tried to time them both myself with a stopwatch, and with Youtube's time codes, and I can't claim to be incredibly accurate with my timing, but I had B/H's combo lift over 12 seconds every time I did it, and B/B's under 12 seconds, if I have the rule correct. At the end of their lift, Nadiia puts one foot down and drags it across the ice briefly, then he spins her again (where she's not touching the ice for a second), then puts her down for good. When Nadiia first touches her foot down, it's well under 12 seconds (I timed it around 10.5-11 sec). When she touches down the 2nd time, I timed it around 12 seconds, so maybe extended.Now I don’t want to start any drama so I’ll preface this by saying I don’t think any scores should be changed or medals reassigned. All of the Juniors competing at worlds were lovely and I look forward to seeing them in the future.
Now all the said, have you heard about the drama going on between British Ice Skating, Skate Canada and the ISU? As we all heartbreakingly know Bekker & Hernandez lost out on bronze due to an extended lift violation. Apparently the time keeper was Canadian and is being accused of not also marking down Bashynska & Beaumont for their lift which it is claimed was also extended. I heard from TSL British Figure Skating have protested… I don’t believe anything can change now but it’s apparently much talked about in the ice dance world.
I’m kind of impressed that this isn’t more generally known.
Since someone asked about Dieck and Smart in one of the live threads from Worlds, I also wondered. Tim only posts himself skating on his instagram account.
And I just found Olivia here:
whatever this all means?
Not sure what you mean by timekeeper, but the person responsible for any deductions pertaining to time violations (late start, program too long or too short, extended lifts in ice dance. ...) is the referee. At Jr Worlds, the referee was the Italian Rossella Ceccattini, who is not connected to Canada in any way as far as I know.Now all the said, have you heard about the drama going on between British Ice Skating, Skate Canada and the ISU? As we all heartbreakingly know Bekker & Hernandez lost out on bronze due to an extended lift violation. Apparently the time keeper was Canadian and is being accused of not also marking down Bashynska & Beaumont for their lift which it is claimed was also extended. I heard from TSL British Figure Skating have protested… I don’t believe anything can change now but it’s apparently much talked about in the ice dance world.
This is referring to the combination lifts in the FD, yes? I tried to time them both myself with a stopwatch, and with Youtube's time codes, and I can't claim to be incredibly accurate with my timing, but I had B/H's combo lift over 12 seconds every time I did it, and B/B's under 12 seconds, if I have the rule correct. At the end of their lift, Nadiia puts one foot down and drags it across the ice briefly, then he spins her again (where she's not touching the ice for a second), then puts her down for good. When Nadiia first touches her foot down, it's well under 12 seconds (I timed it around 10.5-11 sec). When she touches down the 2nd time, I timed it around 12 seconds, so maybe extended.
Bekker/Hernandez actually do something similar, where she touches down then does a little jump, then down again. But she first touches down after 12+ seconds by my count, so already extended, unlike Nadiia.
I think that the time for the lift stops when she puts her foot down the first time (in which case it definitely wasn't extended for B/B), but it's possible I have that wrong.
As for protesting, as far as I understand you can only protest your own scores. So B/H / their coaches / the British fed could protest their extended lift deduction, but not whether another team got one. And you have to protest before the medals are handed out, I believe.
Not sure what you mean by timekeeper, but the person responsible for any deductions pertaining to time violations (late start, program too long or too short, extended lifts in ice dance. ...) is the referee. At Jr Worlds, the referee was the Italian Rossella Ceccattini, who is not connected to Canada in any way as far as I know.
Additionally, the lack of prior extended lift deductions for B/B makes me think that they generally did not have any issues with the length of their combination lift (in contrast to B/H, who unfortunately got extended lift deductions for 5 out of 7 FD this season).
I don't doubt that TSL is spreading drama. It's what they do, they're a drama channel. That doesn't mean they are always right or knowledgeable. That's the thing with rumours and "insider information" - You can't really prove them, can you?I can only say what I heard. I know British Ice Skating did protest their own teams score. Apparently the TSL were going to make a video on it but since it’s WC time I doubt they’ll have time unfortunately. If they do I’ll link it here. As for the original story I reported it’s in their most recent video at about the 35:00 mark.
Like I said I wasn’t advocating for a change in scores or anything, I like both teams. I was more surprised to hear that it was apparently a big story in the Ice Dance world that the fans weren’t talking about.It's ok to be disappointed that B/H lost out on the bronze because of such a small thing, but on the other hand, it is a lesson for all coaches and ice dance teams out there to listen to consistent technical calls and heed the warnings. With a slightly altered lift, that was just a smidge shorter, they might have gotten bronze here.
I'm curious where you heard this from? I haven't seen anyone else talking about it. But then I avoid TSL like the plague, I find them really catty.Like I said I wasn’t advocating for a change in scores or anything, I like both teams. I was more surprised to hear that it was apparently a big story in the Ice Dance world that the fans weren’t talking about.
From what I can see, around 40 of the total 60 dance spots on the GP are already determined by the official rules (top 10 Worlds, top 24 WS/top 24 Season's best, possibly returning split team with Smart/Dieck), and maybe 10-15 of those remaining spots will go to host spots or as second spots to highly ranked teams who weren't at Sr Worlds (Hawayek/Baker, Lajoie/Lagha) and Jr Worlds medalists (at least Mrazkova/Mrazek), but the rest of the spots could really go to anyone. The Brits have the advantage (like Mrazkova/Mrazek and Lim/Quan) that they will never be in a situation where they can't be picked for any GP because of country limits and that they are fairly popular among fans, so feds are more likely to invite them.I think there is an outside chance of Phebe and James getting senior GP assignments? I'm crossing my fingers for it anyway.