- Joined
- Oct 25, 2017
Do you mean the just the Winter or also the Summer Olympics Alain.
I feel there's a big difference between the two.
i think the Winter Olympics suffer because the number of countries that can have access in terms of mountains, facilities, snow and finance for Winter sports is very few. There are only two countries south of the tropic of cancer that medalled (and those are Australia and New Zealand, which are really Northern Hemisphere transplants). By contrast, 78 countries medalled at Rio, whereas there were 28 at Pyeongchang.
Even the cultural aspects of ice dance come in to play with the figure skating team medal, where Japan and China are ruled out of medalling, and the medals therefore become a carve up between three countries, and the event appears an orchestration to give those countries and its individual athletes medals. (The team event is a nonsense that should be dumped- a very obvious celebration of country size and finance that actually makes the olympics look bad by giving athletes from some countries medals with a false equivalency between them and those won individually. The behaviours of those countries towards those athletes and the impact it has on their selecting of athletes and how those athletes behave with regard to selection was one of the many ugly aspects of the run up to this Olympics)
The summer Olympics isn't perfect; and finance and country size will always play a role in medalling. But the access to the sports involved is much more egalitarian (o.k. not dressage) and possible throughout much more of the world; and it just feels so much more international and joyous.
Figure skating's saving grace for me however is its internationalism when done well. Yes there was a lot of flag waving from some countries; and one country in particular whose nationals resembled a fascist rally. But there are also moments when skaters go out there and give us something that communicates internationally, and it's those skaters who provide those moments who really exemplify the Olympic spirit at an event that now feels very detached and different from the Summer games and its spirit (and this is exacerbated by the fact that the Summer and the Winter games are no longer in the same year)
Not only does the Winter Olympics end up 'excluding' other countries that do not have have any winter sports, it also has these competitive events that the rest of the world do not understand and find rather bizarre (e.g., curling). One of my friends remarked how odd these events look like and how strange some of the competition outfits are (e.g., speed skating crotch uniforms). It is easier to relate with the summer games that give better opportunities for other countries to participate. And yes, the figure skating team event is just such a bogus competition! I did not pay attention to it.