- Joined
- Nov 8, 2007
Look at the judging panel: UZB (judge is Russian), RUS, FIN, JPN, HUN, ISR, KOR, ITA, BUL, CHN
Here are the PCS scores in rank order:
27.92 KIM
26.72 KOSTNER
25.80 SEBESTYEN
24.08 POYKIO
23.68 CZISNY
23.56 SUGURI
23.36 ZHANG
21.64 LIANG
20.60 XU
20.28 MARTINOVA
19.52 FANG
18.68 WANG
Only Kim got really high scores. Kostner usually gets scores mostly in the 7s, and here they were all 6s (and she had a good skate).
I think the random selection of the judges played a role here.
First of all, there was no US judge on the panel, even though there were 3 US ladies in the competition. My guess is the ITA judge wasn't randomly selected, but the KOR, FIN, HUN, JPN, RUS and UZB (also Russian) were.
Probably I wasn't clear enough...i simply meant that she wasn't the only one who got low Pc scores. However looking at the ranking you made i would have put Sebestyen lower thean Zhang as many pointed out...I just think the scores were low for everyone except yu na. Even Poykio is too far from Kim and Kostner.
While instead (not looking at the score) i bet many of you would agree on putting cizsny and Zhang almost at the same pc levels (and that's what actually happened!)
Hope I explained better...


