Having not watched the movie and only just realising (thank you, Google) what dress Satine actually wore, and also having just watched Ashley skate anything in red for the first time ever:
1st and only choice - the 2016 white dress with the bling and the HAIR COLOUR!!
Screams glamour and elegance and maturity and I think really has a “wow” factor. The hair is more important that I realised - I remember listening to TSL complaining about her hair last year and thinking, why does hair colour matter?? - but the red hair just looked beautiful. And her blonde hair doesn’t look as dramatic IMO...kinda makes her look too plain and wholesome? And doesn’t draw enough focus to her facial expressions?
Personally, I think that (the ‘16)ensemble was a perfect one.
I don’t think it’s worth it to try and emulate the character by wearing red. The actual dress Satine wore was far too plain IMO, and blinging it up would change it so much that any obvious comparison would be gone. Plus, red is worn by so many skaters, it would just blend in and be another pretty red dress.
I think it’s a sign of Ashley’s acting ability that she doesn’t need to be literal in her costume choice.
So yeah, my vote is the white gown
