Project Runway--Anyone Watching??? | Page 3 | Golden Skate

Project Runway--Anyone Watching???

ToePick, I just read the Jezebel article. The are five PR people showing?? Is that the way it is normally??
If I may answer for ToePick ... yes, every year they have more than the top three show, but only the top three are in the running to win. The others are there as "decoys," to avoid letting word get out of who the actual top three are before the show airs.

ToePick, that's so funny you saw my post on the other board. When I saw Rami, the first thing I thought was, "Ooh I have to post this!"
 
i saw the collections at jezebel! i am so surprised with who my favorite is!!! the designers used several past "americas next top model" contestants. so there's no spoiler anywhere that knows who the real 3 are?
 
I always thought there were four showing but here's a comment I found.

Five finalists is the most ever to show their designs during a Project Runway New York Fashion Week runway show finale.

Has anyone found a good site showing the collections. I found a couple and they only have maybe 4 pics.

I forgot to mention for some reason I think Jillian will be the winner, they have 2 guys & 1 woman, so it's time for another woman.

Dee
 
i think i found the links on the jezebel site to all of the collections...all the pieces...BUT i did not see elisa's collection there...i'll have to go look for it.
 
Finally making my way back over here to catch up on posts!! :) Those crazy weekends with less time at the computer -- they mess with you!

Anyway, thanks Daisies, for explaining the five designers showing bit. Although, I must admit, I still find it odd, and wonder how they are going to explain things on Wednesday. I've heard rumors that there is/was a "two will be out" promo airing on Bravo, though I haven't seen it. Does that mean there are three finalists? Four? Five? It seems like people are saying two decoys, three finalists, but I guess we'll see as things unfold.

Also, Daisies, I'm glad you're sharing that anecdote far and wide -- definitely a great story!! I would do the same thing. :thumbsup:

I knew Elisa had a show this year, but I hadn't really read/searched for much more about it -- it seems like it was interesting and very "her." While I don't share her aesthetic, I admire her ability to stick to her convictions, and still learn and grow as a designer. :bow: Did you ever find pics on Jezebel, ranjanke?

Lastly, Blogging Project Runway has tons of stuff on the final show, and pictures from the show, including all five collections complete and in order. :clap: :clap: BPR It's made its way down a little, but it's still there!! :)
 
Last edited:
i did! thanks everybody! i keep going back to look at the collections...and changing my mind everyday!
 
Elisa's collection is in a post about 3-4 up from here. Her models are a little psycho!!

Anybody watch last night?? Sweet P is out, so do you think Chris or Rami will get the 3rd spot?

Dee
 
Aren't Chris & Rami supposed to do a "design off" for the 3rd spot at Bryant Park, based on the best 3 dresses of their Fashion Week collection? That makes it hard to predict, even from their collections of 12 dresses.

If you were Chris, which 3 of his would you pick?

I'd pick the first one, blue with the woman's face on it.
The 5th one with the multiple necklaces.
The 12th one with his model Marcia with the sequin lined stole

How about if you were Rami?
I'd pick the 6th look with the short burgundy skirt
The long black strapless gown with the strap woven top
His 12th look with the layered gown with the gold & white fabric.

Rami had one dress that was dreadful, a gold dress with no fit, that is my nominee for worst look from the top 4.
 
According to many reports, all 4 of the designers, and including sweet P, showed at Bryant Park but only 3 counted towards who would win, two being Christian and Jilliam.

Also Victoria Beckham is the guest judge for the finale.
 
According to many reports, all 4 of the designers, and including sweet P, showed at Bryant Park but only 3 counted towards who would win, two being Christian and Jilliam.

Also Victoria Beckham is the guest judge for the finale.
I am so confused about that. The show was over long ago, taped and they went to Bryant Park, and we already know that Sweet P is out so why did she show a collection??

Also Victoria Beckham is a judge...do you know if she is or has been a designer??? I don't know if she has?? if she hasn't then why is she a judge?? I guess I wondered the same thing about Debra Messing.

I have my favorite collection. I was a little disappointed in Jillian's. Christian's collection is very high fashion. (not my favorite)

Dee
 
The top 5 showed collections at the Project Runway show in Bryant Park. Only 3 are competing for the prize.

The reason for 5 is to avoid having people find out the top 3 before the show airs. Fashion Week was last week. They are using 2 weeks to edit all the material and for the judges to pick the winner. Thus, the need to hide the top 3 from the general public.

The final guest judge is usually someone who is viewed as a celebrity fashion icon. Debra Messing and Victoria Beckham are known for their talent and their sense of style. I'm actually surprised that Sarah Jessica Parker hasn't been a final judge before this season. They probably wouldn't want her for this year's finale because she was involved in one of the tasks this year.

I hope Chris is in the top 3 instead of Rami. However, I think Christian will win because he can go over the top, which is what they want for a runway show.
 
I thought that for this episode, Christian was the clear winner. Not my taste, really, but clearly he had a vision, was inspired by his art, and really well made.

I suspect he will win the whole shebang, because of his high-fashion collection. My personal favorite collection was Jillian's -- I thought her jackets were amazing. I also liked a good deal of Rami's stuff. I wasn't big on either Chris' or Sweet P's (though whether I liked her collection is moot at this point, since we know she was a decoy). As Tim would say, chacun a son goute.

For the 3d Spot Design-off between Rami and Chris, I would go with:

For Chris: 1) the first piece (blue with face); 2) the eighth piece (red and black worn by Dani(elle) from ANTM; 3) the twelfth piece black with shawl/collar worn by Marcia.

For Rami: 1) the third piece (black and grey -- stunning without the jacket; I think he should have ditched that jacket with the dress entirely); 2) the ninth piece (olive/gold woven bodice worn my Amanda from Season 3); 3) the eleventh or twelfth piece (gold and cream ribbons/black ribbons -- both are stunning and probably his top two pieces, but I think showing the judges two similar pieces, even if not draped, would have ticked the judges off!!).

Overall, based on those looks, I would give Rami the third spot by a landslide, but as I said earlier, that is just my opinion. :)

I don't think Posh is a great judge for the finale. I am not really big on the celebrity judges for the finale at all, because they choose celebrities who aren't even noted for being fashion icons. Posh maybe, but not in a good way (see, e.g., her inclusion on Mr. Blackwell's Worst-Dressed List). I'd rather see people like SJP who are at least noted for their fashion choices (understand why they didn't use her this year), or noted designers or other people related to fashion (journalists, like Fern Malis, for example).
 
I agree with you that Posh Spice is not the person I would have picked to judge.

How about Meryl Streep :)
 
sillylionlove, which looks would you pick if you were Chris & Rami?


If I were Rami I would stay away from draping. He has done it a million times and he needs to come up with something new.

Chris is a drag queen. He needs to bring that to the runway in a haute couture fashion, not drag queen fashion. However, this look is more suited for Paris then New York.

I think in the end it will come down to Jillian and Christian.
 
I am so confused about that. The show was over long ago, taped and they went to Bryant Park, and we already know that Sweet P is out so why did she show a collection??

Also Victoria Beckham is a judge...do you know if she is or has been a designer??? I don't know if she has?? if she hasn't then why is she a judge?? I guess I wondered the same thing about Debra Messing.

Dee

Victoria Beckham has a line of jeans called called either dVb or dBv, I can remember. They are apparently very in demand over in the UK.


I have no idea why Sweet P was able to show a collection. I suspect that this was so that people would not know who the final three were before the show actually aired. Because it has been reported, an not in gossip mags, but in legitimate newspapers that all 5 (sweet P, Rami, Chris, Christian and Jillian) showed in Bryant Park. I suspect that we will only see Christian, Jillians and whowever wins between Rami and Chris on the actualy television show.
 
Okay, I'm really, really excited for the reunion show tonight!!

I'm excited to see what has Carmen crying, to see if Victorya really behaves as much like an ice princess as she does in the previews, to see who won fan favorite, etc.

I love the reunion show every year -- always makes for great TV: good laughs, fun montages, etc. Plus, they don't rerun it as often as other episodes, so be sure to catch it this week.

I'm so giddy, I keep saying "etc."
 
Back
Top