Knowledgeable people are looking at points potential. A clean Abbott can outscore a clean Weir by about 15-20 points because of Jeremy's potential quad (which he has landed cleanly 5 times now in competition), his incredibly difficult transitions, and just overall smarter, COP friendly programs he has over Johnny. Abbott won a GP event this season; Weir did not. Abbott beat Lysacek's TES score in the LP at the GPF (and outscored Johnny in the LP, and should have overall too); Weir did not. A clean Abbott beat a clean Weir in the SP at the NHK Trophy by 5 points. I don't see that Johnny has this superior advantage over Jeremy as you are trying to imply. Jeremy has beaten a clean Johnny this season, but Johnny has not beaten a clean Jeremy. Jeremy has done impressive things this season too.
Well, if you're so knowledgeable, then go back and check the protocols dear, because Weir did beat Lysacek in TES at the GPF LP. And I am sorry, but you're delusional saying things like Abbott beat a clean Johnny and everything else. No one cares who beat whom in what segment of competition (Takahashi beat everyone at the GPF SP. So?) Weir and Abbott met twice this season. Weir beat him twice. No matter how you want to spin it, that's how it's going to stay. And who cares that Abbott won SC this year, it's completely irrelevant to the Weir vs. Abbott debate because Weir wasn't even there. Every time they were together, and judged by the same panel, Weir prevailed.
You can sit there all day and hope for Abbott to one day skate clean or reach his mythical "potential" or whatever. I can just as easily sit there and talk about Weir's potential, his quads in practice or whatever else I can come up with. But if we look at what actually happened, Weir kicked his *** twice, and you just have to deal with that, oh knowledgeable one.