2017 U.S. Nationals Championship Ladies SP | Page 56 | Golden Skate

2017 U.S. Nationals Championship Ladies SP

I thought that all the spark went out of her from the moment the combo didn't go exactly right. She stopped performing and seemed to me to want nothing more than to get off the ice.

Hm. Different feelings, I guess.

She's not an Ashley in terms of expressing throughout her program, but only after finishing all her jumps. There was no difference between the short here and her Worlds short (apart from her 2F). :shrug:

Maybe I just lowered my standards for her in which not imploding is good. :laugh:
 
Just watched NBC's broadcast (thanks, Sabinfire), Johnny mentioned Karen's choreography was done by Jonathan Cassar... Hmm interesting, looks Wiki may be wrong listing Karen? It currently list her choreographying both her SP and LP this season.

I found it interesting to discover she is the same height as Satoko according to Wiki, she sure doesn't look/skate like it.

This is the sort of subtle high difficulty type of music not easy to pull off for someone so young. It is encouraging to see she kept things nuanced, tensioned, detailed, captivated and allowed the choreography to breathe with each phrasing. I do love her kwan like spiral. I have previously expressed this SP is a high risk high reward program because of the little room in the music to allow error without breaking the overall mood effect. Underrated internationally, nice to see it rewarded this way. Karen probably benefitted a bit from Tessa Wong's 65 before her, Caroline's almost 63. Had Gracie, Ashley, goes clean, they'd still be above her. FS pressure will be a good test to this young skater... Mirai beat Gracie in PCS.. wow...

I am glad Mirai is not leading, taking some pressure off her :drama:. On the other hand, everyone in the top 7 is still in contention, especially if Gold/Wagner goes clean. Ice is slippery.
 
Last edited:
I thought that all the spark went out of her from the moment the combo didn't go exactly right. She stopped performing and seemed to me to want nothing more than to get off the ice.

I thought the general performance was maintained throughout the program, with a minor boost after the combo and lull before the flip. I don't like this program at all, but I think it gives her license to be stone-faced and stoic. I'm not quite sure how she would perform/interpret it any better, but that might be because I just don't get this program at all. Last season's was much better.
 
It looks like with some of the underwhelming performances of U.S. ladies during the fall, U.S. fed is saying whoever can bring it is going to get the marks. Sad for Mariah, Courtney, Amber and others who had glitches. Mariah performed well, except for the fall on second half of combo jump. I think Mariah should have placed ahead of Gracie.

The twist is that Tessa Hong despite maturity beyond her years, is 14 and would not be able to go to Worlds. It's really interesting to see Karen Chen skate so well after myriad problems she's had recently. Looks like the trend to white dresses was inspired by Ash's white dress in her last season's free skate.

Anything can happen in the free skates. I really hope Mirai skates well and completes the 3-axel. The only thing about Mirai is the expressions on her face that are sometimes off-putting. The other issue for Karen and Mirai is the tendency for them to get underrotation calls, so that can sometimes end up with them getting reviewed and called for URs that maybe aren't URs.

But worse than the expressions on Mirai's face is the fearful nervous look Gracie tends to have at the boards and out on the ice before her performance. Unfortunately, I do not think that what Frank says at the boards is at all helpful to Gracie.

Maybe Gracie should think about cutting her hair, dying it, and going back to her former coach, Alex.

It's sad for Gracie. It seemed like she'd turned a corner during her teleconference. But she is still shaky with no confidence. If I were her, I'd have to examine whether I truly wanted to skate, and if so decide to break with Frank and go back to Alex, which is not a failure. She definitely needs to figure out how to manage her nerves and gain some new inspiration, and realize that she doesn't need to please anyone except herself!
 
Last edited:
But they're my STRONG FEELINGS!! They have to be right about Ashley being a trash skater because I say so! :drama:



Really? I didn't get that vibe at all. The only "torture" I felt during her short was her winding up for her 3F, she slowed down so much after her split leap!

Come on, she was even confused with the pose, I guess because of joy :sarcasm:. I wish they let her take some anxiolytic before competitions (yes, I know is not possible :ohwell:).
 
Last edited:
There was no difference between the short here and her Worlds short (apart from her 2F). :shrug:

That's definitely not true. Gracie's spins have gotten weaker and the same level of energy wasn't there overall. After the double axel, that transition section she does is so lifeless. For all the talk about her great basics, the footwork sequence here was a bit sloppy too. This program isn't as good as last year's for her either, it's too dark and ambiguous. You can see with the ending, sums up the whole thing. Does she look like an assassin to anyone? Not to me!
 
Interesting SP. Very open, anything can happen in the FS. I agree with the result, Karen Chen was wonderful. Love what Mirai did to her Piano boots, they look much better with the golden heel and sole. Fine performance from her, love that program. Gracie can still win this, I just hope her loop works better than her flip at this point in time, if it doesn't she'll have a hard time in the FS. Ashley is in the perfect position (for her) before the FS, so I guess she's going to win this. Liked her performance, very entertaining, unusual little error on the 2A.
 
I really hope Mirai skates well and completes the 3-axel. The only thing about Mirai is the expressions on her face that are sometimes off-putting.

I think she was deliberately trying to look fierce, or at least serious. She didn't smile even when taking her bows.

As for the triple Axel, I think she can win without it. Maybe her strategy is to save it for worlds (where she cannot make the podium without doing something extraordinary).
 
That's definitely not true. Gracie's spins have gotten weaker and the same level of energy wasn't there overall. After the double axel, that transition section she does is so lifeless. For all the talk about her great basics, the footwork sequence here was a bit sloppy too. This program isn't as good as last year's for her either, it's too dark and ambiguous. You can see with the ending, sums up the whole thing. Does she look like an assassin to anyone? Not to me!

Meh. Low standards compared to her earlier events as I said.

Gracie should be getting better interpretation PCS though according to you. She's apparently good at interpreting the assassination of her career. #euthanasia :dev2:

Edited to add: I missed reading your posts dearest Blades of Passion. :)
 
Last edited:
Come on, she was even confused with the pose, I guess because of joy :sarcasm:. I wish they let her take some anxiolytic before competitions (yes, I know is not possible :ohwell:).

LOL. I still can't believe she posed for her free skate opening before she realized she was doing her short. Maybe we can get her a TUE for Xanax.
 
I think she was deliberately trying to look fierce, or at least serious. She didn't smile even when taking her bows.

As for the triple Axel, I think she can win without it. Maybe her strategy is to save it for worlds (where she cannot make the podium without doing something extraordinary).

Hmmm, we shall see re the 3-axel. Mirai skated well aside from that problem on a jump in the corner. I just think she looks pouty and angry rather than fierce and confident. But again, Mirai's expressions are not as bad as Gracie's nervous Nellie tenseness.
 
Not making Worlds is probably best for Gracie. She'll know she can't take all summer off and be in horrible physical condition when the season starts and also that she can't wallow in self pity for months like she did after Worlds.
 
LOL. I still can't believe she posed for her free skate opening before she realized she was doing her short. Maybe we can get her a TUE for Xanax.

Yes. As I mentioned earlier, Frank doesn't seem to help Gracie. He was telling her to remember to stand up straight. At the boards right before a program, I do not think that kind of comment is helpful for someone like Gracie. Frank seems to make Gracie even more a pile of nerves. Frank should probably be more relaxed and try a different tack with Gracie because she is nothing like Kwan or Lysacek.


I'm listening to IceNetwork's recap from last night and Michael Weiss had some good things to say about the unpredictability of fs, and about how wonderful Karen's program was. But then Weiss said Karen had choreographed it herself, while Johnny had said it was choreographed by Jonathan Cassar. What's the actual truth then? :confused:
 
Last edited:
Hmmm, we shall see re the 3-axel. Mirai skated well aside from that problem on a jump in the corner. I just think she looks pouty and angry rather than fierce and confident. But again, Mirai's expressions are not as bad as Gracie's nervous Nellie tenseness.
I think Mirai looked serious and introverted and that's perfect for that piece of music imo.
 
Well for me Mirai often looks like she's ready to break out crying or punch someone in the face.

Mirai's ending pose was actually more fierce and determined and valiant-looking than her expression when she started her program.


Oh, also, from Karen's backstage interview on IN she indicates that she put a lot of the choreography together, so maybe Jonathan Cassar helped her put it together.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top