I’m behind on this. Just watched the women. I did watch some of the men live (from Mozalev on), but I want to watch the rest before I post my thoughts on the men. I’m “ranking” the ladies’ SPs as follows:
1. Valieva: I agree that thematically this SP is not much different than Storm and whatever it was she was skating to last season, but the way she skated is not. This is the first time I enjoyed watching her. I especially like the step sequence - beautiful movement of the body - and the final spin.
2. Petrosian: A very, very close second. I originally had her first. She’s cute as a button and listens to her music. I like this little lady a lot and hope to see more of her.
3. Muravieva: She reminds me of Usacheva, which is a good thing. Musically expressive, dramatic, but not over-the-top. She needs to tone down the arms, but other than that, I liked her SP.
Tuktamysheva: Her SP isn’t good; it isn’t bad;it’s just…her.
I thought the bottom three were mediocre or worse.
5. Akatieva: Pretty, but there are hundreds of pretty programs out there and hers doesn’t stand out among them.
6. Trusova: Her SP is similar to Tuktamysheva’s, but she’s absolutely not Tuktamysheva so it falls very, very flat. She just comes off as awkward, like a little girl playing dress-up and pretending to be her mother. Just not a good program for her.
7. Samodelkina: The weakest of the bunch. The music cut needs to go in the trash can and she looked as if she were about to fall after every spin. I didn’t like her SP at all.