Should quads per program be limited to balance artistry? | Page 16 | Golden Skate

Should quads per program be limited to balance artistry?

Should quads per program be limited to balance artistry?

  • Yes

    Votes: 73 43.2%
  • No

    Votes: 96 56.8%

  • Total voters
    169
You point out the 90s and 2000s, when some of the best skating happened then, if we strictly speak about artistry. Ito, Browning, Chen Lu, Kwan, Yagudin, Cohen, Savoie, Lambiel, Kim, Asada, Takahashi - take your pick.
Yes, there were some great programs during that period. Including by skaters you have named there.

There were also some fairly empty programs, that may have succeeded by being performed well with clean jumps and good connection to the music and audience, but not a whole lot going on in terms of skating content.

Personally, I prefer the more complex programs with higher skills.
 
Personally, I prefer the more complex programs with higher skills.
If we're talking about this, then I don't feel we need to judge the steps and turns to a higher degree, because IMO, we were already getting skaters like Hanyu until 2022 who were doing rather nice transitions into various elements. We also had skaters like Jeremy Abbott who skated until 2014 (I'll ignore Savoie who stopped in 2006).

Again IMO, this has more to do with judgment and evaluation of the scores we're *already* giving to elements and programs. And mind you that I'm not saying quads shouldn't be limited. Using my own argument from earlier, well people have limited energy. If they spent less of that on quads, they'd be connecting elements better and using better edges.
 
What gives you the impression that she was quite bitter?
I don't know about bitter, but she stated quite clearly in an interview that she would never have a child of her own take up figure skating.

And I am sorry, but this has to be addressed, meanly off topic as it is...

Lombardia had 3 of the top 4 skaters in Malinin/Fa/Kagiyama - but I wonder how many Hanyu fans were there to watch them...
I take it you flew from Canada (tell us, how much are the plane tickets and hotel fees?) to do so, and you spoke to those hundreds of Ilia's American fans and Yuma's Japanese ones - and the equal hundreds of Canadian and other international skating supporters of course - who stumped up the international travel costs in the rink with you? That would be the only justification for such a sweeping condemnation of other people for not spending thousands on the trip to Europe. Skate Canada actually noted the economic benefits to them and to the local economies of the competitions Yuzuru attended, he brought a heap of money to Finlandia the year he and Alina were there. Now, he and his fans are acknowledged as having brought staggering amounts into the Japanese economy as a whole and to local areas there. It's the turn of all those 'Malinin/Fa/Kagiyama' fans to fly all over the world now.

Fans of all sports stars competitive, retired and professional invest their own money however they like and this 'you're not a fan unless you follow everyone!' mantra is ridiculous. My sibling's family are Sydney Swans supporters, and spend plenty to travel to the various cities for matches and on merchandise - if you suggested to them that they are somehow not 'real' AFL fans unless they also attended Collingwood or Hawthorn matches they would look at you like you'd grown two heads. Russell Crowe poured a fortune into his beloved Rabbitohs to help save the club, but no one suggested he had any responsibility to do any such thing for others. So cool it with the 'you are not a fan unless you are underwriting others not spending it up' complaints.

Thank you.
 
Last edited:
Now, back to the current state of splatting skating... because as I have pointed out before, if we the fans are so thrilled when a men's competition doesn't involve most of 'em cactusing all over the rink, and spend 90% of the dance threads working our where the political scoring is going, what hope do we have of persuading the casually-and-we'd-like-at-least-some-of-them-to-stick-around curious to watch? They can get 'Malinin/Fa/Kagiyama' for free, with any splats edited out, on Tiktok after all. If they want to.

(Yes, I'm cranky. I haven't had my coffee yet. Can you tell?)
 
Last edited:
What gives you the impression that Yuna Kim was quite bitter?

Call it Asian politeness, but she was very gracious after Sochi.

She worked tirelessly for the PyeongChang Olympics.

She appeared in 2020 4CCs award ceremonies.

She gives advise to internationally competitive skaters...

Bitterness and burnout can exist, but there's no one reason for them... Yuna had to bear [many burdens and trials] from South Korea all alone.
What I remember most from Yuna Kim's early career was how homesick she was when she was transplanted to Canada at age 15, especially since her English was imperfect.

My coolest memory of Kim in retirement is one time she was invited to address the United Nations in New York.. She began with a few sentences in English and then she told the assembly of world-shakers, OK, put on your translating earphones now, I am going to continue in Korean. (I guess it was her to-the-manner-born politeness that prevented her from adding, "And if you don't like it, stick not up your nose."
 
Last edited:
They can get 'Malinin/Fa/Kagiyama' for free, with any splats edited out, on Tiktok after all.
I remeber back in the 1990s when touring skating shows and made for TV extravaganzas were big in the U.S. There was always a special session after the finale for each of the skaters to do a dp-over to be spliced in replacing the falls. :)
 
I don't know about bitter, but she stated quite clearly in an interview that she would never have a child of her own take up figure skating.

And I am sorry, but this has to be addressed, meanly off topic as it is...


I take it you flew from Canada (tell us, how much are the plane tickets and hotel fees?) to do so, and you spoke to those hundreds of Ilia's American fans and Yuma's Japanese ones - and the equal hundreds of Canadian and other international skating supporters of course - who stumped up the international travel costs in the rink with you? That would be the only justification for such a sweeping condemnation of other people for not spending thousands on the trip to Europe. Skate Canada actually noted the economic benefits to them and to the local economies of the competitions Yuzuru attended, he brought a heap of money to Finlandia the year he and Alina were there. Now, he and his fans are acknowledged as having brought staggering amounts into the Japanese economy as a whole and to local areas there. It's the turn of all those 'Malinin/Fa/Kagiyama' fans to fly all over the world now.

Fans of all sports stars competitive, retired and professional invest their own money however they like and this 'you're not a fan unless you follow everyone!' mantra is ridiculous. My sibling's family are Sydney Swans supporters, and spend plenty to travel to the various cities for matches and on merchandise - if you suggested to them that they are somehow not 'real' AFL fans unless they also attended Collingwood or Hawthorn matches they would look at you like you'd grown two heads. Russell Crowe poured a fortune into his beloved Rabbitohs to help save the club, but no one suggested he had any responsibility to do any such thing for others. So cool it with the 'you are not a fan unless you are underwriting others not spending it up' complaints.

Thank you.
Oh, way to deflect. It's not about my fandom - I'm talking about fans who just show up for a skater and nothing else. There's fans of skaters and fans of skating.

You're missing the point. I'm not talking about investing MONEY in going to attend events, I'm talking about investing TIME and effort to see the various skaters/disciplines in the event. But yeah, had I been able to afford the time and funds to show up to Lombardia Trophy, I totally would have. And I would have stayed to watch the skating first, and wouldn't have showed up to see the big-name skaters and then get up and leave when there were still skaters left to skate. I wouldn't monopolize the full-pass tickets and then only show up to the men's event, and for my fave skaters at that.

Take a look back at the Hanyu Autumn Classic crowds who monopolized seats/bought full-event passes just to watch Hanyu before bouncing.. or the 2014 individual SP crowds in Sochi who headed out after Plushenko pulled out.... you'll learn a thing or two about what constitutes a skating fan versus a skater fan.
 
Oh, way to deflect. It's not about my fandom - I'm talking about fans who just show up for a skater and nothing else. There's fans of skaters and fans of skating.

You're missing the point. I'm not talking about investing MONEY in going to attend events, I'm talking about investing TIME and effort to see the various skaters/disciplines in the event. But yeah, had I been able to afford the time and funds to show up to Lombardia Trophy, I totally would have. And I would have stayed to watch the skating first, and wouldn't have showed up to see the big-name skaters and then get up and leave when there were still skaters left to skate. I wouldn't monopolize the full-pass tickets and then only show up to the men's event, and for my fave skaters at that.

Take a look back at the Hanyu Autumn Classic crowds who monopolized seats/bought full-event passes just to watch Hanyu before bouncing.. or the 2014 individual SP crowds in Sochi who headed out after Plushenko pulled out.... you'll learn a thing or two about what constitutes a skating fan versus a skater fan.
Pot, meet deflecting kettle. "had I been able to afford the time and funds to show up to Lombardia Trophy, I totally would have." Yet you expect other people from other countries, who have far less interest in the competitors in question, to somehow come up with it? They worked and saved and hoarded vacation time... because their own moment of magic was worth it. If 'real' fans - by your definition - begrudged them the full pass tickets (the only ones available thanks to TPTB doing the maths and I note that the Japanese fans who it is claimed always got up and left were at the same time lauded on competition threads and by commentators for being welcoming and cheering on all skaters, which would be hard to do simultaneously, hmmm?), 'real' fans could have gotten in and bought them first. But they didn't, did they? And they haven't since, have they? Most of Ilia's and Yuma's fans passed on that expense, whether they could afford it or not (and again, no reason why they shouldn't, but it's goose and gander). Maybe they will start spending up when the former becomes the celebrity he wants to be. We don't know, wait and see.

But I very much doubt that the Autumn Classic organisers begrudged anyone coming just to see Yuzu, it was better than empty rinks, because Canadians.... oh yes, they don't much go to their own competitions either, do they?

Finally, there is nothing wrong with being a 'skater' fan rather than a 'skating' fan or somewhere inbetween, that's the sort of purist nose in the air mindset that gets mocked enough coming from the self-elected superiors in the 'fine' arts, let alone recreation (see my examples from other sports, there are plenty more). We all get something different from what we love, and if the sport on general is lacking at the minute (which this whole thread seems to indicate!) then the bright spots have to stand out on their own.
 
Last edited:
I don't know about bitter, but she stated quite clearly in an interview that she would never have a child of her own take up figure skating.
That she did. And I can't blame her - I would never send any children of my own to this sport either.
 
And I would have stayed to watch the skating first, and wouldn't have showed up to see the big-name skaters and then get up and leave when there were still skaters left to skate.
People spend their money in ways they like. I used to not like this, but a rather fresh perspective to me when I spoke to people who did this was that they were in a new country they'd never been to before - and they'd like to explore that than stay stuck in an ice rink.
 
People spend their money in ways they like. I used to not like this, but a rather fresh perspective to me when I spoke to people who did this was that they were in a new country they'd never been to before - and they'd like to explore that than stay stuck in an ice rink.
I was at Autumn classic when hanyu was there. There is nothing around the rink to explore. It is about 90/120 minutes away from anything interesting to visit in Montreal. And yes, they came in only when he was skating but left their blankets and banners on the seats which were not assigned so basically blocking fans who wanted to stay for the whole time. At one point. It got so bad that I took part in moving their stuff away so the family of other skaters (world medal winners and Olympic medal winners) were able to sit down. So yeah, people are allowed to spend their money the way they want but some people just have no respect. This being said, I met other Japanese fans who sat there for the whole time and cheered for everyone, not only their favorite. This thread is drifting dangerously. For those interested in quads I saw Hanyu land his first quad loop in a competition. He was able to balance quads and choreography. I think he did four quads in Seimei. It's a long time ago. In his case, the balance was still there. But for most skaters, too many quads is a tragedy for figure skating.
 
I was at Autumn classic when hanyu was there. There is nothing around the rink to explore. It is about 90/120 minutes away from anything interesting to visit in Montreal. And yes, they came in only when he was skating but left their blankets and banners on the seats which were not assigned so basically blocking fans who wanted to stay for the whole time. At one point. It got so bad that I took part in moving their stuff away so the family of other skaters (world medal winners and Olympic medal winners) were able to sit down. So yeah, people are allowed to spend their money the way they want but some people just have no respect. This being said, I met other Japanese fans who sat there for the whole time and cheered for everyone, not only their favorite. This thread is drifting dangerously. For those interested in quads I saw Hanyu land his first quad loop in a competition. He was able to balance quads and choreography. I think he did four quads in Seimei. It's a long time ago. In his case, the balance was still there. But for most skaters, too many quads is a tragedy for figure skating.
These other Japanese fans were also Yuzuru fans, I assume, as you have brought this story a couple of times already before and you have mentioned this detail then :)

It is not about Yuzuru fans as such, it is about people coming to see a great star, and Yuzuru is just the greatest star of this sport.
I was to the Warsaw Cup once where Jason was the star. A big number of people arrived just for penultimate group to see him skating in the last group. They were not interested in anyone else, just wanted to see the great Jason Brown. They were made to wait until a break between groups and asked to take a seat without making too much fuss. Otherwise, no one was making a big deal about it. Volunteers were sent to distribute coffee and tea among the crowd until they were allowed to enter. After the skate, almost everyone was queueing for Jason's autograph, which lasted well into the Pairs event leaving most of the seats empty for them while Jason was giving autographs in the top corridor and talked to fans.
Shall we now pick up on Jason fans and Jason himself, lol?

You see, this is all on organizers.
In tennis, they just shut the door during games, and open them for breaks only. Nobody cares if seats are left empty when paid for, they care only for seats unsold (which I guess is true for any event organizers, really). Especially when it all lasts for so many hours, everyone needs to be cut some slack. They just make sure people don't disturb the players and the games by coming in and out and moving around when the game is on. If they do, they are called out by the umpire and asked to take a seat. The game does not start until they do. Otherwise, no one cares.

I also guess people are much less disturbed by this moving around when they actually do like the skater these unorderly crowds arrived for so they are kind of sympathetic to their cause. When you do not like the skater it all is happening for, I guess you get double disturbed and ready to complain.
 
Last edited:
These other Japanese fans were also Yuzuru fans, I assume, as you have brought this story a couple of times already before and you have mentioned this detail then :)

It is not about Yuzuru fans as such, it is about people coming to see a great star, and Yuzuru is just the greatest star of this sport.
I was to the Warsaw Cup once where Jason was the star. A big number of people arrived just for penultimate group to see him skating in the last group. They were not interested in anyone else, just wanted to see the great Jason Brown. They were made to wait until a break between groups and asked to take a seat without making too much fuss. Otherwise, no one was making a big deal about it. Volunteers were sent to distribute coffee and tea among the crowd until they were allowed to enter. After the skate, almost everyone was queueing for Jason's autograph, which lasted well into the Pairs event leaving most of the seats empty for them while Jason was giving autographs in the top corridor and talked to fans.
Shall we now pick up on Jason fans and Jason himself, lol?

You see, this is all on organizers.
In tennis, they just shut the door during games, and open them for breaks only. Nobody cares if seats are left empty when paid for, they care only for seats unsold (which I guess is true for any event organizers, really). Especially when it all lasts for so many hours, everyone needs to be cut some slack. They just make sure people don't disturb the players and the games by coming in and out and moving around when the game is on. If they do, they are called out by the umpire and asked to take a seat. The game does not start until they do. Otherwise, no one cares.

I also guess people are much less disturbed by this moving around when they actually do like the skater these unorderly crowds arrived for so they are kind of sympathetic to their cause. When you do not like the skater it all is happening for, I guess you get double disturbed and ready to complain.
Autumn Classic was set up in a rink with no seats but benches. The organizers cannot control people and they usually do not have to. I have been to many competitions there because that's often where they hold CQÉ. Never, has there been a problem unless it was went Hanyu fans were misbehaving. And yes, as I said, some of his fans were nice too... but it wasn't the majority.... and yes, I have told that story before because it's extremely upsetting when people hold seats for the entire competition to watch ONE skater and then go.. but leave their blankets on the benches and block the way for everyone else. So no, I am not going to apologize for telling that frustrating story once more.
 
Autumn Classic was set up in a rink with no seats but benches. The organizers cannot control people and they usually do not have to. I have been to many competitions there because that's often where they hold CQÉ. Never, has there been a problem unless it was went Hanyu fans were misbehaving. And yes, as I said, some of his fans were nice too... but it wasn't the majority.... and yes, I have told that story before because it's extremely upsetting when people hold seats for the entire competition to watch ONE skater and then go.. but leave their blankets on the benches and block the way for everyone else. So no, I am not going to apologize for telling that frustrating story once more.
I don't expect you to apologize. I just don't share your point of view.
I guess you might also find it a bit less disturbing if all these crowds arrived there for Patrick Chan. :nod:
I reiterate, I saw the same thing happening for Jason, hardly anyone complained, or even noticed.
For me, they were either breaking the rules or not. If they were ok with the rules, you may not like it but they were doing nothing wrong. If they were not ok with the rules, you have the right to complain to organizers to restore the order. Otherwise, it is just complaining some skaters are way more popular with the public than some others. This may be not flattering to these others but well, people pay for tickets to watch what they want to watch and no one can demand anything else of them unless it is written in the rules that they are not allowed to leave their seats except for breaks. There are events which just have it written in the rules, FS events are not among them, AFAIK.
 
LOL, with retirement comes entitlement, evidently. All that you're griping about -- that is not on the ISU. That is on those particular fans who, as you very rightly hit the nail on the head, came to watch the... ahem, their star — in many cases ONLY for Hanyu, and only satisfied/accepting of the results if they saw him win. Unless you were able to literally clone Hanyu his loyalists will never support any other skater. And even then, they'd get mad and campaign against his clone, lol. You might care about the next gen, but most of them don't give a flying... camel about emerging talent -- they just want him to have the attention, and all the glory, even in retirement.

There are newer stars and newer skaters, even better skaters in some respects. But you will never catch a Hanyu loyalist respecting, let alone acknowledging, new talent. Some are salty about Malinin landing the quad axel. Some mock Shaidorov's artistry to trivialize the combos he does which Hanyu (and most of the men's field) could never even dream of doing. Japan has star talent in Kagiyama and Sato — but how many Hanyu fans are showing up to support them? Lombardia had 3 of the top 4 skaters in Malinin/Fa/Kagiyama - but I wonder how many Hanyu fans were there to watch them... unless Hanyu skated in the gala (and you know they'd buy full passes and only show up to said gala). These are not skating fans — they are skater (singular) fans. It's of course, one's prerogative. But don't blame the ISU for "alienating" a fanbase who was — and still is — dedicated to just one skater... one that has clearly moved on, even if their fans haven't.

It's also pretty rich questioning why the ISU doesn't care about him more... these fans wanted the ISU to burn and fail post-Hanyu (sorry to say, it hasn't)... And now that the ISU has shrugged their shoulders and, quite shockingly, focusing on their PRESENT/active skaters, they wonder why the ISU doesn't welcome him — and them — back with open arms? Ever thought that the ISU doesn't not want viewership to be contingent on one person, ever thought that other skaters deserve to be stars and have their moments in the spotlight? Should Hanyu's face be on the masthead of every World Championships above the actual competitors because he drives in dollars? Is it right for people to treat a legendary skater as some mere commodity/golden goose that the ISU is irrationally missing out on? Come on.

Illogical, unreasonable, and plainly stupid, indeed.
I really couldn't go physically but there was a paid streaming and I actually took my bank card to buy it. Before the buying process, on the site, there was an introduction of each discipline in this competition. In Women, Pairs and Ice Dance, they highlighted the Italian skaters in. Fine. In Men, where they had three Italian, including Matteo Rizzo and Nikolaj Memola which I was eager to watch, they chose instead to promote two overscored pets, those which are a sore to watch precisely because of this overscoring, and which presence had needed an internal struggle before deciding to buy tickets. Well, I left the site rather incensed and put back my bank card in my wallet.
Did you buy a paid streaming, as these promoted skaters were precisely among those you were eager to watch?
I'm saying it, many do without saying.
 
Chen's Olympic FS was pretty egregiously underscored (I mean, 8.00's?!). Some judges placed him ahead of Kolyada with 2 falls ... and multiple perfect scores of 10's were given to Hanyu in spite of sloppy landings/obvious errors on his 2nd 4T and his 3Z.
https://www.isuresults.com/results/season1718/owg2018/OWG2018_MenSingleSkating_FS_Scores.pdf Multiple judges gave his 4T+3T(rippon), 3Z+3A, and FSSp3 just 0's for GOE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nlNDKs0O9tY

Malinin was underscored in his perfect 2023 Worlds SP https://www.isuresults.com/results/season2223/wc2023/data0103.pdf - which got him 7.5/7.75's (his PCS of 40.89 was worse than Tomono who fell, and Vasiljevs/Fa/Rizzo who had multiple errors in their SPs). He had errors in his FS but I still think his PCS of 80.98 was stingy https://www.isuresults.com/results/season2223/wc2023/data0105.pdf (considering 84.02 has been "earned" for a program with 5 falls https://www.isuresults.com/results/gpchn2014/gpchn2014_Men_FS_Scores.pdf). He also underscored in his perfect 2024 Worlds SP. https://results.isu.org/results/sea...------QUAL000100--_JudgesDetailsperSkater.pdf (one judge gave him only 8.00's - worse than skaters who fell like Cha and Miura. For an actually perfect free skate (one of the best of all time) he was still given 8.75s for presentation (some judges marked him worse than Kagiyama who had a fall, and skaters with multiple errors like Uno and Vasiljevs) https://results.isu.org/results/sea...------FNL-000100--_JudgesDetailsperSkater.pdf Thankfully that didn't hold him back from being the rightful winner.

Here's an example of Anna getting a UR call for what I thought was a clean 4F (based on the landing). But the PCS was crazy of course. She generally had a team politicking for her - ones that had their skaters' edge calls ignored by the judges and PCS through the roof for poor programs and good but not 9-worthy components, so using her and Valieva (or any Tutberidze skater) as examples is a bit of a false equivalence. https://www.isuresults.com/results/...------FNL-000100--_JudgesDetailsperSkater.pdf
I'm sorry, it seems that we didn't have the same definition of underscoring. By underscoring, I mean that the skate receives a lower score than what the rules say (also taking into account how a given panel scores); I don't mean, a day where a skater has one of his skates a tad less overscored than what they usually are. To add to this, you started with Nathan Chen who, in addition not to be deserving anything near 8, let alone the actual Components he received, and to have had his underrotations ignored among uncalled errors, had already been that egregiously overscored in the Short Program (chiefly by ignoring his underrotations and overscoring his Components) which artificially put him in the Free Skate where he didn't belong. He's 26th here.


Do you want to enter more into the details?
 
As for Nathan Chen at the 2018 Olympics, he delivered a terrible short program, got the terrible marks that he deserved, and finished in 17th place. He won the LP quite convincingly which moved him up to fifth overall.

In the SP he flubbed all three of his jumping passes. In the LP he attempted 6 quads, did OK on 5 of them. Duh -- mess up on three out of three jumping passes = low score. Land 6 quads = high score. PCSs were not good, not bad in either, and in any case had little effect on the scores or placements. Nothing to see here, folks. Skate bad, 17th place. Skate good, 1st place.

There is no reason why we should use one skater's success as a cudgel to bash other skaters. Let Yuzuru Hanyu enjoy his two Olympic gold medals. Let Nathan Chen enjoy his 2022 gold medal. Let Ilia Malinin skate in Milano and... we'll see. ;)
 
Last edited:
Take a look back at the Hanyu Autumn Classic crowds who monopolized seats/bought full-event passes just to watch Hanyu before bouncing.. or the 2014 individual SP crowds in Sochi who headed out after Plushenko pulled out.... you'll learn a thing or two about what constitutes a skating fan versus a skater fan.
Talking about Sochi, these were not specifically Plushenko fans, these were Russsian skating fans who just wanted Russia to win. They were not screaming Plushy Plushy but Russia Russia, and just left when no Russian was left to compete so they lost interest.
Yuzuru when asked about it then said that he was perfectly alright with them leaving, better this than trying to disturb other skaters when yelling during their skate. If skaters don't mind, why would fans make a fuss?
But otherwise I just think all this distinction between fans of a skater and of skating is meaningless and just made up to criticize fans of most popular skaters frowned upon by fans of their rivals. In most sports people are fans of one particular club, or of their national team, or of a selected athlete, and everyone thinks it perfectly alright and nothing else is expected. Never heard of FC Barcelona fan considered not a fan of soccer because they did not root for Real Madrid, or a Rafa Nadal fan accused of not being a fan of tennis because they rooted for Rafa only, and did not care for Novak. Actually it is pretty common in tennis, that people buy whole day tickets, cause these are on sale, and turn up only at night for the last match of the day when the greatest stars play. Very common indeed.
My general feeling is just FS did not really have such a huge star for some time and people forgot what it is like when an athlete is really popular with the general public.
 
Back
Top