Kimmie had a growth spurt, which kinda took her out. Between 2006 to 2012, nationals was a free for all, in which anyone could win as long as they skated clean. Our ladies were a mess. It was such a struggle transistioning from 6.0 to IJS. Without a stable lady like Michelle, it took away the stability that ladies skated relied upon for decades. Ashley provided some of the consistency needed, while Gracie gave ladies skaters a blueprint to transistion into IJS programs.I know that internal competition can push competitors, but that's not the end all be all. Sometimes the motivation is found from within. What motivated Mirai to even learn a triple axel? No one in the US was doing it. Yes, her external motivation was the Olympics, but she needed to improve to get there. There was a lot of internal motivation to get better, especially when many had written her off. Also I think this quote by Teddy Roosevelt is instructive (as well as an answer to any snarky 'well she missed it in the individual' posters):
http://thinkexist.com/quotation/it_is_not_the_critic_who_counts-not_the_man_who/12121.html
Other things play into confidence, not just clean skates and good practices. This goes back to what happened with Kimmie Meisner. She was put in the position where she had to prove that her success wasn't a fluke and was cast off the minute she failed and some new young skater came along. This kills confidence. This created a CULTURE where this became the norm. Knowing you can be cast off the minute you fail or are less than perfect, creates an atmosphere that kills confidence. The fruit of this was what happened with Gracie Gold. Failure happens. You learn to work through it. That said, TPTB need to be more supportive and not so quick to cast aside skaters who fail.
There are debates about nationalising the system which isn't a bad idea. Incentivising hard skills is good. However, the CULTURE has to change because this is a recipe for failure. The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over and wxpecting different results.
The problem with Gracie, is that she was expected to be a world champion out the gate. She hadn’t had a lot of experience competing against competitors at her level. Her ascent was fast. Suddenly she was expected to handle the expectations of a nation while facing off with competitors that were just as good if not better than her. Evgenia OTOH was challenged as a junior and learned competitive nerves because of it. It’s something that juniors and seniors need to learn before they can be expected to win.
Winners are made not born. At novice level, local level competitions are easy for skaters that have semi consistent triples to win. If the most talented novices, juniors and seniors competed against each other more often then they’d develop better competitive skills that would serve them well competing internationally. It’s takes more just talent at jumping and spinning to become winners.
