2021-22 Russian Women's Figure Skating | Page 146 | Golden Skate

2021-22 Russian Women's Figure Skating

Status
Not open for further replies.
5) telling a thirteen year old girl on the internet that her coaches don’t have their best interest in mind because they let her do what she loves (without apparent pain) during a competitive season is prwtt
I mean sure. People have boundary issues online. Personally, though, I have yet to figure out why we were being served with a smorgasbord of videos about her injury/non-injury/whatever we are supposed to think about it now. What was the actual point? And why did whichever journalist or telegram hooligan run with it? And why are there long posts still discussing it and "defending" random coaches and skaters on this thread, and the fan fest of the skater concerned, with "research" and "evidence" which can basically be summed up as "obsession". Do you not see how it looks or...?

In general, why is there this obsession with posting every single second of the life of a bunch of junior girls on multiple accounts? Not just even Plushenko. It is horrid. If the adults had any interest in protecting these children from online trolls, they'd at least take the first step and log off.
 
1) A ligament injury is not “more serious” than a broken bone, you can train on injured ligaments, you cannot train on a broken leg or toe (re: Anna)

2) after checking your translation yes, it’s an ankle ligament— not hip as insta translates it to. HOWEVER it is still not a broken bone, and people’s perception of injury severity is still incredibly warped

3) people skate on one skate all the time, for edge exercises, to keep the feel of the ice, etc. This is routine

4) ligament injuries especially to the ankle which is such a complex joint are often not bothered by many actions— it is only specific ones that are. For example, when I’ve sprained my ankles before playing soccer I would have the whole thing swollen and purple and bruised all season long but would only feel pain when turning a certain way, or misstepping to land on the side of my foot— sprinting, running, and most actions unaffected. This is also why sprinters and runners who tear their ACL will not actually get them repaired until the end of their professional career— they don’t need to move that particular direction when sprinting short distances, especially if braced for track turns.

5) telling a thirteen year old girl on the internet that her coaches don’t have their best interest in mind because they let her do what she loves (without apparent pain) during a competitive season is pretty messed up.

My final words are STOP GASLIGHTING 13 YEAR OLDS into believing they’re experiencing abuse because you have an overly weird fixation on every single thing that happens in their life and career. It’s creepy. This fixation on her doing a f%&* cartwheel or skating on one skate is creepy.
Lol, tf is this text. Who’s gaslighting which 13 year olds? :palmf: And who said anything about abuse?

Is anyone here talking to Veronika? o_O can she read English?

it wasn’t me who said it’s more serious, it’s people in the thread, I merely said that it’s what they were discussing. I simply wanted to put the record straight about what Plushenko said himself, because you got it wrong.

Anyways, you sound like you need some rest, maybe moreso than Nika ;)
 
Last edited:
I mean sure. People have boundary issues online. Personally, though, I have yet to figure out why we were being served with a smorgasbord of videos about her injury/non-injury/whatever we are supposed to think about it now. What was the actual point? And why did whichever journalist or telegram hooligan run with it? And why are there long posts still discussing it and "defending" random coaches and skaters on this thread, and the fan fest of the skater concerned, with "research" which can basically be summed up as "obsession". Do you not see how it looks or...?

In general, why is there this obsession with posting every single second of the life of a bunch of junior girls on multiple accounts? Not just even Plushenko. It is horrid. If the adults had any interest in protecting these children from online trolls, they'd at least take the first step and log off.
Plush announced an injury of his student as to why she wouldn’t be attending an international competition, and a bunch of people ran with it, leading to him posting clarifying content as an addendum. Is he the most tactful with his student management? No not really. But I think making professional announcements on behalf of your underaged skater are significantly different than speculating abusive environments when not backed up by the skaters themselves.

Sasha liking or not liking a comment about Eteri’s environment being abusing for example warrants speculation because she is the skater in said environment, not some random hit piece journalist looking for clicks.

The fan fests border on obsessive to me but I would presume most of the participants, like those in her fan clubs are likewise children. Remember Aliona and that creepy dude stalking her? Acceptable behavior for a 12 year old who isn’t making suggestive remarks, but if I was secretly some 45 year old man on here talking about how beautiful she is in a compendium of 30 photos would be weird.

In general I think the whole idea of these forums can attract super toxic individuals who take people’s careers way to seriously. They should be here to discuss the quality of skating and programs, well wishes, etc. not to fixate on every small detail of a CHILD’S personal life. That’s especially true when people start making comments about coaching staff intentionally and/or needlessly harming their students when they are 6 degrees of separation from the rink.
 
Plush announced an injury of his student as to why she wouldn’t be attending an international competition, and a bunch of people ran with it, leading to him posting clarifying content as an addendum. Is he the most tactful with his student management? No not really. But I think making professional announcements on behalf of your underaged skater are significantly different than speculating abusive environments when not backed up by the skaters themselves.
Making "professional announcements" is different from posting videos repeatedly and documenting daily life. And as I said, it's not just him, it's a lot of people.

I don't have much else to say. I have little interest in reading novel-length posts about how WELL ACTUALLY this and that was perfectly fine with "evidence". Something happened, people reacted.

The fan fests border on obsessive to me but I would presume most of the participants, like those in her fan clubs are likewise children.
Oh, how I wish that were true, about some of these "researchers".

Now, if we can focus on the skating that will happen again, at some point, soon enough, that would be great.
 
Funny. When such discussions were going on about the Tutberidze group, everything was fine. A huge number of posters on various forums (including this one) an infinite number of times searched for abusing in the Tutberidze group (how did Kira Korpi write? now I will Google " The Tutberidze Factory is a sign of the inhuman culture that our sport accepts. ", oh yes, old Kira Korpi burns)

But it was worth touching on the Plushenko group - Oh! how many immediately started talking differently :) "13 year old", "you are stalkers" (And this is despite the fact that, unlike Eteri, where people just fantasized tall tales, everything is clearly shown - how children with injuries skate on ice.)

Shall we speak directly? Personally, I like to talk directly :) You don't like Tutberidze because she is our flagship, who turned russian women's figure skating into an irresistible force. This and only this is her greatest sin in your eyes. And Plushenko is the one who puts sticks in her wheels and your sudden love for him of most of you is based on this.
 
Last edited:
Funny. When such discussions were going on about the Tutberidze group, everything was fine. A huge number of posters on various forums (including this one) an infinite number of times searched for abusing in the Tutberidze group (how did Kira Korpi write? now I will Google " The Tutberidze Factory is a sign of the inhuman culture that our sport accepts. ", oh yes, old Kira Korpi burns)

But it was worth touching on the Plushenko group - Oh! how many immediately started talking differently :) "13 year old", "you are stalkers" (And this is despite the fact that, unlike Eteri, where people just fantasized tall tales, everything is clearly shown - how children with injuries skate on ice.)

Shall we speak directly? Personally, I like to talk directly :) You don't like Tutberidze because she is our flagship, who turned russian women's figure skating into an irresistible force. This and only this is her greatest sin in your eyes. And Plushenko is the one who puts sticks in her wheels and your sudden love for him of most of you is based on this.
This is laughable considering the reason I even got back into watching figure skating as an adult who hadn’t known anything about it since I was 4 or 5 watching the olympics with my mom was because of the Eteri camp. A video of Zagitova’s Don Quixote at the Olympics was recommended to me on YouTube, and from there I found Zhenya and the 3A who are still my favorites of all time. I have no care for one coach or the other, think Kira is out of line in her discussion or again an environment she is not in just for clout, stopped watching the Skating Lesson because of a similar gossipy, dramatic, speculative style of skating discourse, and have significant respect for Eteri who reminds me very much of my favorite coaches from high school.

This nonsense about preference of coaches due to hatred of another is silly and childish. Why would I hate someone who has renewed my interest in skating, brought back for me an old hobby with my mom, etc.

Very absurd dichotomy always presented here.

Anyways, I’m wishing Veronika a speedy recovery, and I look forward to seeing her back on the ice. It’s a shame her first competition went well and mow she’s out.

I really have nothing more to add.
 
This is laughable considering the reason I even got back into watching figure skating as an adult who hadn’t known anything about it since I was 4 or 5 watching the olympics with my mom was because of the Eteri camp. A video of Zagitova’s Don Quixote at the Olympics was recommended to me on YouTube, and from there I found Zhenya and the 3A who are still my favorites of all time.
Slightly off-topic maybe, but I read this wrong and thought you were saying that you got into figure skating because you found Alina's Olympic Don Quixote when you were 4 or 5. I almost got sad because "Wow, 2018 was so long ago? I'm getting old..." and then realised that wasn't quite right and snapped out of it.

I need more sleep.
 
Noelle Streuli’s cut of Vivaldi’s Seasons makes me more sad for Aliona’s. I think it displays the nature of the four compositions so much better, even if it only has Summer and Winter. Also that opening really suits her style of skating better.

Just really makes you realize how questionable some of the music cuts coming from Sambo are sometimes 😅
 
Of all those who skated in the previous stages, only Berestovskaya without a medal.

Akateva đŸ„‡đŸ„‡
Petrosian đŸ„‡đŸ„‰
Zhilina đŸ„‡
Samodelkina đŸ„ˆđŸ„‰
Zinina đŸ„ˆ
Kulikova đŸ„ˆ
Muravyeva đŸ„ˆ
Berestovskaya ---

I'm sorry, forgot Zakharova, she is also without a medal
 
Shall we speak directly? Personally, I like to talk directly :) You don't like Tutberidze because she is our flagship, who turned russian women's figure skating into an irresistible force. This and only this is her greatest sin in your eyes. And Plushenko is the one who puts sticks in her wheels and your sudden love for him of most of you is based on this.
She just wins too much, so all the spotlight is on her. It isn't that she doesn't have flaws, but it's the fact that other coaches too have them but don't get bashed the same.

Undestood this when Alysa Liu started landing quads at the very same age than Trusova but her coach didn't get the same outrage.
When some famous coach got students complaining about physical abuses very publicly but it didn't cause an outrage.
When another coach said that one of his teenage students who had just left him was mentally ill and that another was lazy af and no outrage again.
When other coaches are building factories of 11yo quadsters but it isn't a problem.
When other skaters are having severe back injuries and serious mental health issues but we only see Eteri's ones.
When other coaches get several injured skaters or skaters who lost too much weight but no one bat an eye. I mean if Sinitsyna was an Eteri's student the drama would have had no end.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top