- Joined
- Jun 21, 2003
There were, and are in every sport, strict rules about under what circumstances and time limits an official is allowed to "correct" a ruling.Were they... not allowed to change the card? This is a serious question btw, this is such strange news to me.
In Tim's case (I didn't go into details above) the issue was that they ISU had just changed some of the scoring details and the system in place at the Olympics used a slightly different scale than had been used in internation competition up to that point. The errant judge marked on the old scale instead of the new, and the discrepency was not caught in time.
(By the way, the real shocker at those Olympics was that the odds-on favorite for gold, Emmerich Danser, completely fell out of one of his figures and finished 4th, putting the contest up for grabs.)
Last edited:



) and quads (Shimada, Sumiyoshi, possibly Watanabe) but I don't see who could do them consistently and qualitatively enough to blow Mone out of the water. Shimada and Nakai are in the age when big jump consistency & quality starts going downwards. Kawabe's 3A and Sumiyoshi's quad are not fully there yet. Watanabe is improving but, if she wants to add a quad, her programs will be a mess at least for one season. Actually, Miyake might be consistent with her 3A; she's just entering the age when senior jumps start getting better (24 y.o.), but I'm not convinced that everything else in her programs will be good enough to beat Mone.