6.0 judging for CoR Ladies

[Li'Kitsu]

Can you say that Carolina's FS wasn't the best of the night, artistically, or that Kanako's wasn't the best, technically (using the 6.0 standards?)

I'm not very knowledgeable when it comes to 6.0, but I would have had Murakami 1st artistically too. She was just so underscored at this event.

 

[David21]

My goal wasn't to attack Julia, I actually like her skating a lot! I just wanted to share my opinion about this CoR results, that are for me a bit unfair, so I tried to "judge" this competition with the 6.0 system (being totally unbiased, so not considering for example the home crowd advantage) and see what the result would be... One of the posters here actually said that my score for Carolina was a bit too low! This is just my opinion, of course: if you want, you can post the scores you'd give and we can discuss about the differences...

None of us is totally unbiased but I still appreciated reading this thread

 

[Moment]

Kostner wouldn't receive anywhere close to 5.8 in the second mark for her LP???

 

[dorispulaski]

There was an odd vbulletin problem with this thread. I think it is fixed now, and you should all be able to post here again.