general comments about Emily & Kimmie
I don't believe that a clean Emily can beat a clean Kimmie, either in terms of technical or artistry. Neither of them were that impressive this past season, and yet Kimmie still consistently topped Emily, and rightfully so.
Going forward, isn't Kimmie also attending college part-time at U of Delaware? That should be less demanding for Kimmie and given that she already trains there. On the other hand, Emily will be moving to Massachusetts from Long Island, NY, and the all these changes will widen the gap between her and Kimmie.
That said, there is also the question of what Emily's true goals are in terms of education and skating. Maybe she's testing the waters freshman year. Maybe she just wants to keep doing both simultaneously, recognizing that her skating might slip but perhaps that's okay with her as long as she's enjoying herself. Well, power to her; she has every right to make her own choices.
Frankly, I think the bigger concern is that in general, the US ladies have been slipping in world ranklings. Neither Emily nor Kimmie can compare to their international peers, either in jumps or style, assuming everyone skates well.