IMO Fumie has the best dresses - all of them are wonderful and classic. Ando's SP dress was gorgeous. Shizuka's SP was cool, but I've never liked the LP dress: spiders?, and IMO all black is too harsh on her. Plus she could use a longer skirt.

I liked her Umbrellas SP dress. Irina's SP skirt was too long; thought she was channeling an ice dancer. <g> Thought her QR dress was better than the one she used in the LP. Didn't like either of Cohen's; the old swan was OK (it looks better in person than on TV).
I liked MK's SP dress. Liked the Natls. blue strappy one, too, though. And the liked the salmon-LP dress, even with the gold stuff (better without, but I understand why she added it, even though it didn't help). Must admit I laughed when I read Michelle described as "busty" - compared to Vika?!
Eman's SP was nice. Not fond of his LP. Didn't care for either of Joubert's. Liked Johnny's LP, not sure on the SP. Blech on Mikey's. Liked Lindemann's LP but not SP.
Disliked Den/Sta's free dance costumes. Too much fabric, but her wedgie wasn't so bad this time. Navka/Kost had the best costumes. Heck, Tatiana has a gorgeous body, why not show it off? <g> Didn't care for the sun/moon of Kati & Rene. Actually, I liked his, but not hers. Moon was too huge across the front, and I didn't like the mismatched colors.
That's all I can come up with now...