When I was writing my post about Patrick's relationship with the audience, I began to wonder how two people can watch the same skater, and even the same performance by that skater, and have two completely different reactions to it. Everyone in this thread is profoundly moved by Patrick's skating and yet there are many others on GS who say that Patrick's skating "leaves them cold," that he doesn't emote well on the ice, that he's not artistic, etc. How is this possible? Is it simply a matter of taste? I have a feeling that the reasons are hard to pin down. Takahashi is an amazing skater who has moved me on several occasions but not every time he takes the ice. Hanyu could become like Takahashi as he matures. Plushenko is a great jumper with astounding consistency and tenacity, but again, he doesn't “move me” like Patrick does. Other skaters who move me like Patrick does are G&G, S&Z, and Michelle Kwan. Jason Brown does too and he will probably be my favorite male skater at the 2018 Olympics. Ubers of Takahashi, Hanyu, and Plushenko probably feel as profoundly about them as we do about Patrick. What makes a skater moving to some but not to others?
I am asking this here because I didn't want it to turn into a “fan war” in The Edge, with people defending their own favorite skaters by putting down other skaters and then criticizing those who have different opinions. Call me a scaredy cat, but some threads there get crazy in a hurry. :yes: