I think it might be because she always chooses the same type of music, year after year. We don't see much in the way of personality from her during her performances.
Caroline may very well have different moods and choreography in her capabilities that will be tapped into later as she matures. I say give her a chance and who knows, she may surprise you. Right now though, she is only a 2nd season senior skater - she has potentially LOTS of time on her side.
Good luck Caroline!
One of the best Caroline montages I've seen...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cHjegdLGb48
Everyone's got different taste.
I don't like watching her because she's slow and her jump technique is horrendous.
She bores me because, like nubka said, I really don't think her skating relates much to the music. I think you could change the background music and her expression wouldn't change. She's also very much in the "ice princess" mold, and personally, I am a bit sick of that and enjoy skaters who do something different.
Wow. Among young US ladies I like Ashley most...