I think rather than Jin being lowballed in scoring (i think that's debatable personally), it's more likely that Vincent has much more intense competition domestically, and that when he's placed on the Worlds team he carries the burden to maintain the 3 spots for US men next year. Whereas for Jin's situation, his meltdown at Worlds resulted in China having only one spot next year, but not many fans reacted to this situation since they feel China has no one else to send anyways. Sadly most assumed Han Yan is retiring even without any official announcement from CSA.
:yes: That is one of the best posts I have read :thumbsup:! You have inspired me to come out of lurk mode and write a response, risking the chance of receiving another warning from the GS Forum Moderators and having my post deleted

.
Vincent has repeatedly mentioned how he felt it was his
duty to represent the US well in competitions. He injured his back just before Worlds, but still went out there and valiantly gave it his all, performing a personal best SP. Unfortunately, he couldn’t sustain through the injury and wasn’t able to pull it through on the FP. Unlike Shoma, he doesn’t have the great PCS and reputation to suffer the TES deductions. But like Shoma, Vincent went out there despite his injury and performed to the best of his ability. That is the sign of a true fighter and champion. I have more respect for him than certain skaters who pull out just before the competition because they fear of not being able to deliver and beat the other skaters.
Getting back to the topic of US Men, I do wish Vincent would cut down on the quads and focus more on the other aspect of skating. I understand what he had to do last season to get himself a shoot for the Olympic spot but his multi-quad program really took away everything else in his performance. He's young and passionate about the sport, I hope his coaching team can guide him to the direction towards a well balanced skater, instead of relying on USFS to promote that on paper through media. The new system might encourage him to focus on quality instead of quantity, I don't like how he is being hyped by having all the 'quads' when he doesn't rotate them most of the time. But I believe if he's given more time to work on finetuning one or two quads at a time he can improve on the overall quality of his jumps.
Absolutely agree 100% and more :agree:. I am Vincent's biggest fan and have expressed the same sentiment many times. I did wish that he would talk with Borser when Ice Fantasia was first announced at the beginning of April and secretly hoped that he would switch teams. This was before all the other skater moves were announced. I am going to give his team the benefit of the doubt for now since Tammy is relocating to Colorado. But it was clear that TomZ pushed him way too much and wasn't able to gauge the realistic expectations of a first year International senior, having to perform under the shadow of Nathan and the other artistic veteran skaters. He had way too much pressure and expectations to handle.
In a recent NBC Bay Area interview around the time of the San Jose SOI show, Vincent said: “It’s just hard when you focus that much on the quads. So this season, I’m trying to make a huge change artistically." It sounds clear to me that he realizes the pitfalls of the quad-heavy and artistically-lacking programs. Vincent is a very smart kid and he is very grounded. Now that the Olympics is over, he should be able to take his time to work on his SS and presentation skills to improve his PCS, and hopefully TomZ and Christy Krall can focus on fine tuning his quad rotations. I am hoping Tammy's presence will help balance out TomZ's intense quad-focused training regimen. He's even having Camden try 4A's when he should be working on establishing a good solid SS and jump technique for all his skaters, first and foremost.
I have high hopes for Vincent and

that Lori and Jeffrey will choreograph suitable programs for him, where he can showcase and focus on his expressive musicality, instead of just doing one jump to another.