Personally, think the 4S she did without the rippon in one of the Russia Cup stages last season was the most impressive. Maybe the lack of rippon really made her focus on it, and she jumped it with all her might - "I WILL not fall". Maybe this will make it more consistent for her, though.
Either way, I think if we see too many rippon quads + the "max BV, min effort" layouts this season, maybe the ISU will be pushed to change some rules. After all, all of one person doing a 0-7 program was enough to make them change the rules - and these things are far less impressive to me than Zagitova's accomplishment even if that was debatably flawed. Personally, hope a lot of the Japanese, Americans, and Russians go for one or the other or both.