- Joined
- Feb 27, 2014
It's hard to say because everything is unknown. It's probably a long shot to do something like having another organization for favorite skating but a lot of the B level &c or the skaters are left twiddling their thumbs.Sure, that's possible for countries with a lot of depth (Japan, Korea, Russia and the US), but at least 2 of the countries you mentioned don't have that (Georgia and China), which is why I assumed you meant top skaters (of at least these countries).
And even within countries with a lot of depth, skaters will still be put into uncomfortable situations to choose between international competitions in this new league you proposed or retaining ISU-eligibility. In Russia, the top skaters are indeed far enough removed that it's almost impossible for skaters like Nastya Guliakova to catch up, but in Japan, Korea and the US, the technical level of the top skaters is not so much higher than that of the skaters ranked outside of the top 10. Gaining consistency and favour of the federation, as well as some of the top skaters retiring or going through a rough patch would be enough to allow previously lower-ranked to become top skaters in their country - And if they're not ISU-eligible, that could mean missing out on a once-in-a-lifetime chance of making it to the Olympics despite being competitive enough.
The thing is, there are tons of smaller ISU competitions that are open to anyone and allow unlimited entries per discipline for each ISU member, but many of the skaters just outside of the top 10 or 20 don't take advantage of these competitions (or at least not the Russian skaters). Instead, it is often skaters far removed from the top that show up here (I mean skaters that don't even make it to Russian Cup stages).
Do you think that lower-ranked skaters will be more willing to compete in this new league? Will they have to be baited by more exposure or better price money than those ISU competitions? From what it seems, one of your goals would be to allow as many skaters as possible the opportunity to compete internationally, but that could become really expensive (in price money and organisational costs) really quick.
And if everyone can enter, will lower-ranked skaters from other nations be interested in competing in this new league when they'll have to compete against the top Russian skaters and/or an unlimited number of very good Russians (because the depth in Russian skating is extremely deep)?
Don't get me wrong, it's not necessarily a bad idea, but there would definitely be big obstacles in the way to creating such a parallel organisation to the ISU.
I hope the Russians get back as soon as possible but it's all up in the air for who knows how long. I'm someone who doesn't like a lot of sports anymore they've gotten to political and such. I like saying the underdogs make it in figure skating so I would not be adverse to following an event that did not have the top guns.
I am sure there would be major obstacles to creating a parallel organization to the International skating Union. Maybe they can start off with a lower level or something for just challenge your level competition. I don't know what's going to happen but if the Russians are gonna be banned for like 2 or 3 years they as well try to do something else.
I wouldn't even put it like they're taking away from the ISU that organization is still probably going to have its top skaters I'm talking about the 2nd and 3rd To your skaters who don't get a lot about opportunities. I don't know if the money could be there to create another should you're skating organization. Just trying to run some idea of my people.