Mens Free Skate

[carolinefan177]

Total scores the same, but winning the FS breaks the tie -- so Evan wins.

nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

 

[Germanice]

Why does Lysacek win with a tie score?????????? :banging:

 

[Hsuhs]

Congratulations to Evan for winning his 2nd consecutive title.

Next year better, Johnny.

To those who posted and re-posted details/ results, and just kept company - thank you!

 

[annlfs]

oh johnny you tried so hard, i can't believe this...

 

[yelyoh]

I think whoever wins the long wins the comp if it's a tie.

 

[KBell]

Why does Lysacek win with a tie score?????????? :banging:

b/c he won the free skate I'm guessing - their TOTAL score was the same not the score for the fs

 

[london_calling]

So depressed right now. I thought it was going to be Johnny this year. Still proud of him for what he has accomplished this season.

 

[Germanice]

Congratulations to Johnny for a wonderful competition!
To me he's the true winner!

 

[cocovica]

oh johnny you tried so hard, i can't believe this...

for me..he is champion, because he tried finally the quad

 

[KBell]

Congratulations to Evan for winning his 2nd consecutive title.

Next year better, Johnny.

To those who posted and re-posted details/ results, and just kept company - thank you!

yep I had a blast too and a minor heart attack a time or two! Now I have an hour to regroup before it comes on TV.

 

[Hikaru]

nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo....

oh, well....

noooo

 

[Vicky458]

Wouldn't the highest PCS scores win in that case for the LP?

What? Why doesn't the highest PCS scores win? What are the rules in the COP? This is crazy!

 

[raphael]

I didn't think it would be even probable to tie with this scoring system

seems a little unfair though that they both can't win

 

[taylorfax]

Whatever, if it's a tie. (How is that POSSIBLE). Johnny wins in MY book. Geeeez. lol

 

[purplecat]

I was so rooting for Johnny! I was all set to say my favorites all won Nationals too. Oh well, as one of the NBC commentators said (can't remember who of the eight! LOL But it might've been David) what Johnny needs is to skate great at Worlds and get a medal (since Johnny's won Nationals repeatedly and Evan's won World medals.) Hope that happens for Johnny this year! Good job to all the guys though. Should be a great final to watch!

 

[yelyoh]

In the short Evan got higher PCS. I think if they were to perform the same at World's this would not be the case. Oh well at least JW proved he can compete again with Even in the LP and land a quad combo.

 

[badknees]

omg, i love the orange smile that is banging his head against the brick wall!!

 

[1795]

congrats to who ever won...ha
and let the battle of "who should've won" roll on for 100s of posts

Yay Stephan!!! He's going to worlds now, I assume!

stephans in first, total segment score:228.06

Go Stephan!!!

isn't it stephen? but woohoo! worlds!

 

[museksk8r]

ahhh, come on, they could have gone down in the history books as the 1st shared National title holders.

Anyway, congrats to Evan for gold, Johnny for silver, Stephen for bronze, and Jeremy for pewter! What a GREAT competition guys! THANKS!!

 

[WishICldSkate]

Tied? Oh, my!

I love to watch both Johnny and Evan skate, but I was pulling for Johnny to pull off the win. I think it's intriguing that they tied. What are the odds? But I'm actually surprised that Evan's been outscoring Johnny on PCS lately. I'd have been willing to bet that Johnny was considered a better artistic skater than Evan, but I guess that's not true (anymore).