I do much prefer artistry expressed via skating and body movements a la Carolina Kostner and Patrick Chan.
But do you think she should score lower? Preference is one thing...I prefer mostly the skaters who aren't receiving the top scores but I don't think the scoring needs to match my preference. To me the difficulty and execution of the steps and transitions are quantifiable where as a perceived artistry is heavily dependent upon personal tastes.
I'm honestly curious as to your opinion and I'm not trying to make a point here.