It's an opinion, that's fine, but neither commentator is an Ice Dance expert. Chris Howarth skated Singles decades ago, and has since been a Coach. Catherine Whitaker is a Tennis broadcaster. I saw on her Twitter she said FS is her first love. Good to know she's a fan and not just doing a paid job of work. But don't regard any comments they make as worth anymore than your own opinions. Plus they're not even in the arena, but watching in a studio at the Eurosport headquarters in Paris.
Exactly! Their opinions are fun to listen to but none of them have ice dance expertise.