Dzepka right now is better than Valieva at any point since December 2022. Valieva did not produce much after the age of 16.
I think I was still sipping the Valieva kool aid back in that 2023-24 season, while she was very solid in her short program, the free skate when I watch it now -- I feel embarrassed for her. I don't know how the skating skills can be higher than the 7's. It's just so slow. She gives up every time she performs it as well.
Valieva's skating skills have declined even more since before the ban. I find everything so sloppy about her skating now. She has wonderful elements in isolation (except her jumps), but everything in general wild, hurried and out of control. Maybe it's the fault of her new coaches? Under Eteri every movement was refined and had purpose (at least they tried to do that with the Black Panther program it was just horribly choreographed and Valieva no longer had the skill/fitness to perform the intricate parts of it).
What Dzepka is accomplishing without someone like Eteri breathing down her neck is extraordinary.
There would be no Valieva without Eteri.
I hope Valieva turns it around, but the ban expired 6 months ago, she has probably been performing in shows for nearly two years now (at least since July 2024). So it wasn't a true ban she only had 6 months off ice (and even then she probably hired rinks to practice)

. I'm not hopeful.