Overall, I think the ice dance podium is just. However, I think the Shibs had the biggest victory. Weaver and Poje hung on to their dominance and scored well in the free. Chock and Bates had a very respectable 105 but were clearly disappointed that they didn't get first. The Shibs 101 was the best of the season. It may have been in the 103 range if Alex hadn't messed the twizzles. Someone mentioned that Maia sparkled and Alex seemed off overall. I think I agree with that. I think the big message the judges are saying to the Shibs is "Go out there and give us a 'perfect' program and we're inclined to reward in the 105 range." That could very well make them Worlds podium material. Maia and Alex are fun loving but quiet and very smart skaters. I think there is still time to make a mark for this year. It will be interesting to see if Marina still fits into the equation for next.
Yes. Despite a third place finish and being firmly placed behind Madison and Evan overall, the Shib Sibs are figuring it out and learning how to grow. To get into the 170+ range (total score) tells you that the judges are appreciating them as a team. Despite the error, i thought it was their strongest outing this season.