What do you mean by "accepting"? It's not like anyone can take away her medal or something.
Has she won Worlds? Yes.
Is Kaetlyn the best female skater in the world currently? No. If she would be, she would won Olympics, or at least any other serious international competitions in the past years. In fact she never even was close.
It's actually somewhat reminds me of Sotnikova's situation, with only difference being that it was Olympics in her case.
Slutskaya and Kwan and Asada have never won the Olympics. And they were regarded as the best at many points. Hughes was a multiple World medalist and won the Olympics but still many would have brushed it off and called Slutskaya or Kwan best in the World.
Asada was well off the podium in 2014 Olympics, and then won 2014 Worlds -- but should we simply say Sotnikova didn't compete and Lipnitskaia/Kostner were off their game, Mao Asada wasn't the best skater in the world at that point she won the title?
These are the world rankings.
http://www.isuresults.com/ws/ws/wsladies.htm
Reigning World Champion is atop the World rankings, so yes, as per rankings she is the best in the world. She has this ranking because she's done well at international events, like a bronze in the Olympics and silver at Worlds last year.
I'm also curious as to how you define serious internationals competitions... and how/who you would consider best in the World:
- Medvedeva didn't win the Olympics, so she's not the best female skater in the world according to your post.
- Zagitova winning Olympics makes her best in the World to you -- but then she didn't even
medal at Worlds -- so how can she be best in the World?
- you say winning the Olympics makes someone best in the World but then criticize Sotnikova for having only won the Olympics - unless you acknowledge that when Sotnikova won and Hughes won and Arakawa won, they were the best in the World?
- Osmond having the highest World ranking somehow does not make her the best in the World, but when other skaters are ranked #1, are the world rankings suddenly legitimate to you?
One thing is for certain: Osmond is the reigning World champion -- and will be for at least the next 11 months -- and no amount of derision or attempts to trivialize her will change that.
