Valentina & Max not only went clean, they skated better than the two teams ahead of them, eh. This is the way the game is played though. U.S. fed already know who they want to send to Worlds. P/ F will have to continue proving themselves.
Like I said in the Practices thread, Jim Peterson always has his teams ready for U.S. Nationals. They show up and show out, sometimes when least expected to do so. I was impressed by Valentina's crispness and surety on the jumps, which she doesn't always display. But they were both on point. I say keep it up for the fp Valentina & Max!

Make the judges work!
IMO, Ellie & Danny were slightly better than Emily & Spencer. And Valentina/ Max skated better than both those teams. Of course, Emily/ Spencer medaled on the GP and went to GPF. And they are favored by U. S. fed. E&S have a lot of talent, but they also struggle with injury issues. Had they skated clean, they would be further ahead. Meanwhile, Ellie/ Danny looked prepared and comfortable with each other. There was a double turn on a sbs jump landing by Ellie, yet a good performance overall -- on a par in ability with Emily/ Spencer.
So the middle range 60s scores of C/H, K/O, and P/F were definitely managed and massaged for the outcome most preferred. Still, it's up to the skaters to continue battling and let the chips fall where they may. The fed still reserves the right to send who they prefer to Worlds in any case.