So that would be 5th PCS score at cup of China. And 3A from amber,alysa,rinka and ani, lzlo from Alysa.
hard fall at the beginning that desestabilizad her but she managed to regroup and the end was stronger
Respectfully, I disagree. Rino's SP, for example, outclasses Adeliia's, even if the scores don't (and likely will never) reflect that.
I do agree with like 70% of these statements. But it does not matter.
You dont think she was faster in the SP than Alyssa and Amber...? They are all scoring under 220. I don't know why anyone thinks Adeliia is getting under 230 with 2 quads. In the last 3 seasons isn't Kaori the only one who touched this number? This is just ridiculous at face value.
Ok well to break past the endless detailed analyses: the discussion is about if Adeliia wins with 2 quads. I think she clearly does. If she got 31.5 in a debut with worse skating than yesterday, she is not getting less than 230 with two quads, and nobody else is touching this number except Nakai who is historically giga inconsistent unless she is a new skater this season which we will understand in due time. The point is you have to claim Adeliia is scoring under 230 with 2 quads which seems completely impossible to me.
She is scoring 220 in Russia, internationally she scored 209. Let's say she can take it up to 215 as she had some minor stumbles. 215 is a score all Japanese, all Americans and Loena are capable off.
The thing is she does not have 2 quads...
Thats exactly what I'm saying... of course she isnt scoring 230 without ultra-c. Maybe we misunderstood each other... a common narrative is that she needs all of her ultra-c, that is, at least 4 jumps to be the favourite. I completely disagree. 2 4Ts are enough. If she even gets 32-33 then she cannot score under 230 with 2 clean quads. It is completely impossible. If this is your position then we agree. All of her ultra-c will push over 240. If she is scoring 260 in Russia it is impossible for them to cut off over 20 points on GOE (which she got fair scoring on) and PCS (which she is still getting above average, likely at least 32 while top girls with reputation are rarely pushing 35).
Ok but we're also discussing all the other girls assuming they will be in their best form. None of them are either.
Maybe just maybe, yes.
The overall score for FP is nonsense. Sorry. Much too high. Seems to be a "strategic score".I genuinely am unsure what was up with the scoring though. Like what was the point? The ChSq getting +1.63 is really preposterous... she just did a knee slide.
Why would you think I disagree about the scoring when you just quoted my post saying it was overscored? Of course she isnt as good as December that was her career peak. I only disagree in that I'm not worried about her. She is off the couch and looked amazing in the SP. Fell in the FS and doesn't seem bothered by it.The overall score for FP is nonsense. Sorry. Much too high. Seems to be a "strategic score".
The 4T was a fall right when she started to slide for the jump. No confidence, no trust. It was a "slide in panic for the upcoming fall".
The rest of the program was not on the same energy level than in December. Everything was slower, everything was with less energy. Jumps are still shaky. Her knee slide was "interesting". Everything was without the "last bit of confidence" and "power". Even in Beijing she seemed to be more "confident" and "powerful". Don't know what happened the last weeks. But more and more I'm worried about Adeliya.
Based on her potential the FP was a catastrophe.
I know, you will disagree as always. But I tend to be harsher than Eteri with "my girls"
Last Oly everyone was top form, even young you was outside of front runners pulled amazing program.
