Well... Yagudin's "contemporary handsome" if not "classically handsome" then?

What I meant to say is, if you show the average person still pictures of Plushy and Yagudin circa. 2002, I suspect most to say Yagudin is the handsome one (and they would consider Plush a bit odd-looking with the mullet and big nose). The gap would probably be closer if it's Yagudin vs. Plush circa. 2006. However, there are a lot of people who have Yagudin's style of looks, while you can pick out Plush immediately from a crowd.
...I've read my share of horrific fanfics, but fanfic about real people is too creepy even for me.
I'm not sure if I find either Plush or Yuzu "hot" even though I like them both as skaters. Plush looked absolutely stunning performing Nijinsky, but I suspect it's 'cause his movements were so beautiful that it didn't matter to me what he looked like. I actually had an RL experience (won't go into it in too much detail) that proved to me how movement can affect what we perceive as attractive. The guy went from attractive to ugly to attractive again with movements alone.
Plush does go for more "sexy" performances than many skaters, but especially in the early years, I feel like he's joking around rather than actually trying to be sexy. I did get a good laugh at this one Once Upon a Time in America performance, where the camera shot him Elvis-style from the waist-up so we wouldn't see the hip-shaking.

Yuzu channels a bit of Plush in his Sochi SP, with the swagger, but I definitely don't advise him going for, say, Tango Amore anytime soon. Many girls find him cute in the "bishonen" way, but I dunno... I like pretty guys just fine, but Yuzu never came across as Asian heartthrob hot to me.
EDIT: Yes, he'll be in Artistry on Ice in China (as one of the headliners, judging by the layout of the poster)! Will he be skating in Japan too though?