No, friend, this is exactly what happened in this case.
Every judge ranked Gogo first, except the Canadian judge. And who did he rank first? Roman.
I'm telling you it fits the pattern, friend. Before the competitive season began, Gogo wasn't REALLY on anyone's list for the Olympic selection. Not really. Then when Keegan announced his return, it was all about whether Keegan or Roman would get the spot. And now suddenly, Gogo seems a legitimate threat, perhaps even the early favorite.
And that wasn't in Skate Canada's plans. So what does their judge do? Ding Gogo just a bit by being the only judge to place him second, and he elevates Roman with a first placement - when nearly every other judge had Roman in 3rd or 4th (only the Japanese judge ranked Roman 2nd). And it's not just the placements - it's the points. The Canadian judge scored Steven lower than every other judge on the panel, and he scored Roman the highest of any of the judges.
It's obvious. Roman is the fed's "preferred" skater. At least until they see what Keegan's got.