I might not be objective. I tried to be watching top 3. After P/C retired I lost interest in ice dance, as I felt that this cycle nobody would come close to the magnificent D/W, V/M and P/C. Then it was the scandal so I was not interest to see the Cizeron with the new partner.
This was my first watch of their FD’s this season.
I was never a big fan of P/G with the exception of their Vincent FD. I rooted so much for them that I actually had a nightmare they were disqualified before the FD. To me their FD was the highlight of the night, they were clean, sharp, in perfect tune and syncron. Their moment had all the feels. Beautiful.
Never was a fan of Maddie or Even in particular as a pair - huge fan of hers though. They were crisp clean and had the champions vibe. Like they could do it with their eyes closed type of thing. I liked P/G better but I can see why Maddie and Even scored higher at least om GOE.
Now for the French team. Guilame is the best male ice dancer in the world. He is statuesque, posture, edges, speed. One of a kind. I can see why the judges went bonkers with them, as she is also an amazing skater with lots of qualities and they match well. But the fact that they were a new team showed. We all saw him with Gabriella. Such a glued team, the syncron and movements - they were moving as one sole body on the ice. In the end yes I think the French team had the speed edges flow and movements of the night. But it felt short. If you ask me who deserved it I will go rewatch P/C from 4 years ago. At least now I am aware that despite how amazing Cizeron is, the heart and sole of that team was Gabby. I realised just how much I miss watching her in particular.