2025 Canadian Nationals: SR Women's Free Program | Jan 19, 2025 | Page 5 | Golden Skate

2025 Canadian Nationals: SR Women's Free Program | Jan 19, 2025

To be fair, Marie-France gave us such a performance, if I were a judge, I would have scored uliana lower than MF d'amour here. This is actually what I see on the score card. This was not it. Yesterday was even better performance wise.
I said that Marie-France deserved her higher PCS, I just criticised the inconsistency of judging across competitions. Either Uliana's PCS at Challenge were too generous or they were too low here, because there were not 4 points of difference between those two performances (especially not with a fall at Challenge).
 
doing a great job in her second year 👏 👏 👏

1 Uliana Shiryaeva

# Executed

3Lz+3T 10.10 0.93

3F 5.30 -0.08

3Lo 4.90 0.70

2A 3.30 -0.99

FSSp2 2.30
0.39

ChSq1 3.00 0.07

3F(e)+1Eu+3S
9.94 -0.80

3Lz+2T 7.92 0.51

2A 3.63 0.33

StSq3 3.30 0.42

CCoSp4 3.50 0.65

FCCoSp2 2.50 0.64
 
I said that Marie-France deserved her higher PCS, I just criticised the inconsistency of judging across competitions. Either Uliana's PCS at Challenge were too generous or they were too low here, because there were not 4 points of difference between those two performances (especially not with a fall at Challenge).
I had understood ... But let's say you're a judge and you gave 6 to MF.. how do you not give 5 to uliana? You got to do so. It is why we cannot compare scores from different events. Top skaters had byes at challenge. If they give 7s to uliana, they'll need to give what to Maddie?
 
I didn’t like her free leg on the jumps. Very wild. Her arms Ion take off in some too. That’s going to make for inconsistent jumping always.
 
Back
Top